以磁共振成像结构病变替代放射学骶髂关节炎对中轴型脊柱关节炎患者分类的影响
研究在SPondyloArthritis Caught Early队列中,评估将骶髂关节MRI结构病变加入ASAS中轴型SpA分类影像学标准、或以之替代放射学骶髂关节炎的效用。294例慢性背痛患者中,采用侵蚀/脂肪病变≥5的界值,加入MRI仅使3/294例额外分类为axSpA;替代mNY时286例(97.3%)分类不变,5例(1.7%)不再分类为axSpA,3例(1.0%)新分类为axSpA。结论认为在多数早期患者中,结构病变替代或加入X线不改变ASAS分类。
要点
- 采用侵蚀/脂肪病变≥5界值,加入MRI结构病变仅使3/294例额外分类为axSpA。
- 以MRI结构病变替代mNY,286例(97.3%)分类不变,5例(1.7%)不再分类为axSpA。
- mNY与MRI结构病变(侵蚀/脂肪病变≥5)一致性为中等(κ=0.58)。
核心结论
- 在多数早期起病患者中,以MRI骶髂关节结构病变(脂肪病变和侵蚀)替代或加入传统X线,不导致ASAS axSpA分类不同。
- 作者认为结构病变(脂肪病变和侵蚀)可可靠地用于ASAS axSpA分类,既可加入也可替代骶髂关节X线。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入SPondyloArthritis Caught Early队列中慢性背痛≥3个月且≤2年、起病年龄<45岁的患者,共294例。
- 由两名校准良好的阅片者评分骶髂关节MRI STIR(炎症,MRI-SI)、MRI T1加权(结构病变,MRI-SI-s)和X线。
- 采用先前提出的MRI-SI-s阳性界值(基于无SpA患者中<5%的患病率):侵蚀≥3、脂肪病变≥3、脂肪病变和/或侵蚀(侵蚀/脂肪病变)≥5。
- 按ASAS axSpA标准对患者进行分类。
主要发现
- 294例中29例mNY阳性,32例MRI-SI-s阳性(侵蚀/脂肪病变≥5)。
- mNY与MRI-SI-s(侵蚀/脂肪病变≥5)一致性为中等(κ=0.58)。
- 采用侵蚀/脂肪病变≥5界值,加入MRI后3/294例额外分类为axSpA。
- 采用该界值替代mNY,286例(97.3%)分类不变,5例(1.7%)不再分类为axSpA,3例先前未分类患者(1.0%)分类为axSpA。
- 其他界值(侵蚀≥3和脂肪病变≥3)结果相似。
关键数值与推荐
- MRI-SI-s阳性界值:侵蚀≥3、脂肪病变≥3、侵蚀/脂肪病变≥5(基于无SpA患者中<5%的患病率)。
- mNY与MRI-SI-s(侵蚀/脂肪病变≥5)一致性κ=0.58。
- 加入MRI(侵蚀/脂肪病变≥5)额外分类axSpA:3/294例。
- 替代mNY(侵蚀/脂肪病变≥5):分类不变286/294例(97.3%),不再分类为axSpA 5例(1.7%),新分类为axSpA 3例(1.0%)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论认为结构病变(脂肪病变和侵蚀)可可靠地用于ASAS axSpA分类,既可加入也可替代骶髂关节X线。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To investigate in patients with chronic back pain of a short duration, the utility of adding structural MRI lesions of the SI joints to the imaging criterion of the Assessment of SpondyloArthritis International Society (ASAS) axial SpA (axSpA) criteria and the utility of replacement of radiographic sacroiliitis by structural MRI lesions. METHODS: MRI STIR (inflammation, MRI-SI), MRI T1-weighted images (structural lesions, MRI-SI-s) and radiographs of the SI joints of patients in the SPondyloArthritis Caught Early-cohort (chronic back pain: ⩾3 months, ⩽2 years; onset <45 years) were scored by two well-calibrated readers. Previously proposed cut-offs for a positive MRI-SI-s were used (based on <5% prevalence in no-SpA patients): erosions ⩾3, fatty lesions ⩾3, fatty lesions and/or erosions (erosions/fatty lesions) ⩾5. Using the definitions of MRI-SI-s, patients were classified according to the ASAS axSpA criteria. RESULTS: Twenty-nine of 294 patients were modified New York (mNY) positive and 32 were MRI-SI-s positive (erosions/fatty lesions ⩾5). Agreement between mNY and MRI-SI-s (erosions/fatty lesions ⩾5) was moderate (κ: 0.58). Using the erosions/fatty lesions ⩾5 cut-off, 3/294 additional patients were classified as axSpA (adding MRI). Using this cut-off instead of mNY (replacing mNY), classification did not change in 286 patients (97.3%), but 5 patients (1.7%) would not be classified as axSpA and 3 previously unclassified patients (1.0%) would be classified as axSpA. Similar results were seen for the other cut-offs (erosions ⩾3 and fatty lesions ⩾3). CONCLUSION: Assessment of structural lesions (fatty lesions and erosions) on MRI-SI instead of or in addition to conventional radiographs does not lead to a different ASAS axSpA classification in most of the patients with early disease onset. This suggests that structural lesions (fatty lesions and erosions) can be reliably used in the ASAS axSpA classification of patients, as both addition and replacement of radiographs of the SI joints.
引用
- Bakker PA, van den Berg R, Hooge M, et al. Impact of replacing radiographic sacroiliitis by magnetic resonance imaging structural lesions on the classification of patients with axial spondyloarthritis. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2018. PMID: 29584927. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/kex532
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。