提升年轻风湿科医生与研究人员同行评审技能:EMEUNET同行评审导师计划
EMEUNET为弥补评审技能培训在常规教育中的缺失,依托风湿学期刊开展真实同行评审导师计划;4年间18名导师与86名学员参与,完成计划的33人中13人(39.3%)成为《风湿病年鉴》独立审稿人,调查与定性访谈显示兴趣高并识别出主要优势与不足。
要点
- 4年间18名导师、86名学员参与,完成计划的33人中有13人(39.3%)成为《风湿病年鉴》独立审稿人。
- 调查与定性访谈显示对该计划兴趣高,并识别出主要优势与不足。
- 作者认为该计划是创新且成功的同行评审培训方式,持续评估与改进是其运作关键。
核心结论
- 作者认为该计划是同行评审培训的创新且成功的方式,持续评估与改进对其运作至关重要。
- 作者认为EMEUNET同行评审导师计划可作为风湿病学以外领域同行评审培训的参考。
研究设计与样本
- EMEUNET设立面向风湿学期刊的同行评审导师计划,让学员在经验丰富的导师指导下、并在风湿学期刊支持下参与真实同行评审。
- 本文为观点类文章,概述该计划及其成果,并讨论其潜在局限性。
- 该计划已通过问卷调查与定性访谈进行评估。
主要发现
- 4年间共有18名导师和86名学员参与。
- 完成计划的33名参与者中,有13名(39.3%)在培训后成为《风湿病年鉴》(Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases)的独立审稿人。
- 调查与定性访谈显示对该计划兴趣很高。
- 识别出的主要优势为顶级期刊参与和学习机会,主要不足为名额有限和宣传不足。
关键数值与推荐
- 完成计划的33名参与者中13名(39.3%)成为《风湿病年鉴》独立审稿人。
- 4年间参与者为18名导师和86名学员。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为该计划可作为风湿病学以外领域同行评审培训的参考。
- 原文未据此给出具体临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文自述该计划的主要不足为名额有限和宣传不足。
- 作者指出持续评估与改进对该计划运作至关重要。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Although peer review plays a central role in the maintenance of high standards in scientific research, training of reviewing skills is not included in the common education programmes. The Emerging EULAR (European League Against Rheumatism) Network (EMEUNET) developed a programme to address this unmet need. The EMEUNET Peer Review Mentoring Program for Rheumatology Journals promotes a systematic training of reviewing skills by engaging mentees in a 'real world' peer review experience supervised by experienced mentors with support from rheumatology journals. This viewpoint provides an overview of this initiative and its outcomes, and discusses its potential limitations. Over 4 years, 18 mentors and 86 mentees have participated. Among the 33 participants who have completed the programme, 13 (39.3%) have become independent reviewers for Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases after the training. This programme has been recently evaluated by a survey and qualitative interviews, revealing a high interest in this initiative. The main strengths (involvement of a top journal and learning opportunities) and weaknesses of the programme (limited number of places and insufficient dissemination) were identified. Overall, this programme represents an innovative and successful approach to peer review training. Continuous evaluation and improvement are key to its functioning. The EMEUNET Peer Review Mentoring Program may be used as a reference for peer review training in areas outside rheumatology.
引用
- Rodríguez-Carrio J, Putrik P, Sepriano A, et al. Improving the peer review skills of young rheumatologists and researchers in rheumatology: the EMEUNET Peer Review Mentoring Program. RMD Open. 2018. PMID: 29531790. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2017-000619
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。