文献速递类风湿关节炎

风湿科医生对类风湿关节炎疾病活动的整体评估差异极大

Physician global assessments for disease activity in rheumatoid arthritis are all over the map!
PubMed 文献 · RMD Open · 2018-02-21

该研究调查加拿大风湿病学会的风湿科医生,用0到10分对类风湿关节炎(RA)病例的疾病活动进行医生整体评估(MD globals),分析评估者间差异及医生年龄、性别、执业环境和经验的影响。结果显示同一场景的MD globals跨度高达7.6分(满分10分),线性混合模型示MD globals评分显著受年龄和经验影响,多变量分析示两个年龄类别及年接诊600-800例患者者呈临界显著性。

要点

  • 同一RA病例场景的医生整体评估分值跨度最高达7.6分(满分10分),医生间差异极大。
  • 对同一患者病情变化方向医生意见一致,但对恢复或恶化程度的判断常不一致。
  • 线性混合模型示MD globals评分显著受医生年龄和经验影响,多变量分析示部分年龄类别和年接诊量呈临界显著性。

核心结论

  • 研究强调需要为RA疾病建立评估标准,或可开发、标准化并商定一套0到10分的患者场景目录,以减少风湿科医生评分间的巨大差异。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究调查加拿大风湿病学会的风湿科医生,使用覆盖疾病活动谱的RA病例,由医生按0到10分进行疾病活动整体评估,采用Kappa、组内相关系数(ICC)和线性混合模型分析。

主要发现

  • 共有109名医生回复调查(回复率约30%)。
  • 同一场景的MD globals分值范围最高达7.6分(满分10分),表明医生间存在巨大差异。
  • 部分场景描述了同一患者的变化,受访医生对患者恢复或恶化程度的判断常不一致,但变化方向一致(即若好转则所有医生均认为好转)。
  • 单独分析医生相关因素时,线性混合模型示MD globals评分显著受年龄和经验(由医生排名、年接诊患者数和临床实践年数反映)影响。
  • 多变量分析示两个年龄类别(56-65岁,P=0.049;65岁以上,P=0.058)及年接诊600-800例患者者(P=0.056)呈临界显著性。

局限性

  • 调查回复率约为30%。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Physician global assessments of disease activity (medical doctor (MD) globals) are important outcomes. MD globals may vary based on their age, gender, practice setting and experience (number of patients seen per year and years in practice). METHODS: We determined the variability of MD globals, surveying rheumatologists from the Canadian Rheumatology Association using rheumatoid arthiritis (RA) cases rated by MD for disease activity from 0 to 10. Cases were developed to span the spectrum of disease activity. Kappa, intraclass correlation (ICC) coefficients and linear mixed models were used. RESULTS: 109 responded to the survey (approximately 30% response). The range of MD globals for the same scenario was as high as 7.6 out of 10, indicating vast discrepancies between physicians. Some scenarios outlined changes in individual patients; however, physicians surveyed were often in disagreement as to how much the patient recovered or worsened but the direction was the same (ie, if better all agreed). When physician-related factors were analysed separately, MD global scores were significantly influenced by age and experience (ranked by a physician, number of patients seen per year and years in clinical practice) in linear mixed models. Multivariate analysis revealed borderline significance for two age categories (56-65 years, P=0.049; over 65 years, P=0.058) and those who have seen 600-800 patients per year (P=0.056). CONCLUSIONS: This emphasises the need to establish evaluation criteria in RA for disease. Perhaps, a catalogue of patient scenarios that range from 0 to 10 could be developed, standardised and agreed on to decrease the wide variability of ranking by rheumatologists.

来源:RMD Open,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Turk M, Pope JE. Physician global assessments for disease activity in rheumatoid arthritis are all over the map! RMD Open. 2018. PMID: 29531782. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2017-000578

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。