干燥综合征患者负担:评估严重程度所用指标范围与异质性的综合文献综述
该综述检索2005年1月至2015年9月Embase文献,纳入157篇聚焦干燥综合征患者方面的文章,发现评估腺体、腺外及功能领域的指标种类繁多,多数未在干燥综合征中验证,非验证视觉模拟量表锚词各异阻碍研究间比较;药物临床试验中较常用EULAR干燥综合征患者报告指数评估症状、36项简表评估生活质量。
要点
- 干燥综合征患者负担评估指标范围广、异质性大,多数未在该病中验证。
- 非验证视觉模拟量表锚词多样,妨碍不同研究间比较。
- 药物临床试验中较常用EULAR干燥综合征患者报告指数和36项简表。
核心结论
- 评估干燥综合征患者负担的指标范围广、多样性大,多数未在该病中验证。
- 需要专门在干燥综合征中验证、能显示改善的患者报告结局终点,应聚焦对患者重要的生活质量方面,并可能涉及功能变化而非患者报告症状。
研究设计与样本
- 检索Embase 2005年1月至2015年9月发表的文章,纳入聚焦干燥综合征患者方面的研究论文、临床与诊断综述及验证研究。
- 共157篇文章符合入选标准。
主要发现
- 观察到用于评估腺体、腺外和功能领域的评估指标种类繁多。
- 许多不同的非验证视觉模拟量表使用范围广泛的锚词来量化干燥综合征疾病负担,阻碍研究间比较。
- 相对较少的药物临床试验使用验证量表:EULAR干燥综合征患者报告指数最常用于症状评估,36项简表用于生活质量评估。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估干燥综合征患者负担时需注意现有指标多为非验证工具,研究间可比性受限。
- 药物临床试验可参考较常用的EULAR干燥综合征患者报告指数评估症状、36项简表评估生活质量。
局限性
- 检索仅覆盖Embase 2005年1月至2015年9月,可能遗漏其他数据库或时间段的文献。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
CONTEXT: The severity of Sjögren's syndrome has been evaluated using a wide variety of clinical measures and patient-reported outcomes (PROs). This may contribute to the lack of clarity concerning the burden of Sjögren's from the patient perspective. OBJECTIVE: To perform a comprehensive peer-reviewed literature analysis of the patient aspects of Sjögren's, focusing on PROs, to investigate the complexity underlying the evaluation of the syndrome and to elucidate the discordance between the different measures. METHODS: We searched Embase for articles published between January 2005 and September 2015. Research articles, clinical and diagnostic reviews, and validation studies with a focus on patient aspects of Sjögren's were selected as the primary information source. RESULTS: 157 articles met the eligibility criteria. A wide variety of assessment measures used to evaluate glandular, extraglandular and functional domains were observed. Many different, non-validated Visual Analogue Scales, with a wide range of anchor words, were used in the quantification of Sjögren's disease burden, impeding comparisons between studies. Relatively few clinical trials of drug therapies used validated scales: European League Against Rheumatism Sjögren's Syndrome Patient Reported Index was used most often for symptom assessment and 36 Item Short Form Survey for quality of life (QoL). CONCLUSION: A wide range and diversity of measures are used to evaluate the patient burden of Sjögren's; most are not validated for use in this disease. PRO endpoints, validated specifically in Sjögren's, that demonstrate improvement are needed. These measures should focus on QoL aspects important to patients and will most likely involve gauging change in function rather than patient-reported symptoms.
引用
- Hammitt KM, Naegeli AN, van den Broek RWM, et al. Patient burden of Sjögren's: a comprehensive literature review revealing the range and heterogeneity of measures used in assessments of severity. RMD Open. 2017. PMID: 28955493. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2017-000443
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。