健康评定问卷(HAQ)在不同社会人口学因素间的等效性:QUEST-RA研究分析
基于QUEST-RA研究中9022例类风湿关节炎患者,采用项目反应理论模型检验HAQ各条目是否存在与社会人口学因素相关的应答偏倚。结果显示年龄、性别和工作状态在部分条目存在相关DIF,但经DIF调整后复合HAQ评分变化很小(Δ0.02-0.07),MD-HAQ补偿偏倚最佳(Δ0.02)。社会人口学因素对复合HAQ影响总体可忽略,但跨性别比较功能时仍需谨慎。
要点
- 部分HAQ条目在年龄、性别和工作状态上存在相关DIF(OR>1.1或<0.90)。
- DIF调整后复合HAQ评分仅小幅增加(Δ0.02-0.07),MD-HAQ补偿最佳(Δ0.02)。
- 跨社会人口学因素解读HAQ时首选MD-HAQ,但跨性别比较功能仍需谨慎。
核心结论
- 社会人口学因素在个别HAQ条目上产生应答偏倚,但对复合HAQ评分影响很小。
- 跨社会人口学因素解读HAQ时MD-HAQ更优,跨性别比较功能时仍需谨慎。
研究设计与样本
- 基于QUEST-RA研究9022例类风湿关节炎患者的数据分析。
- 采用潜变量建模框架下的项目反应理论模型检验DIF,模型等效于以条目级HAQ评分为结局、潜特质「身体功能」及社会人口学因素为预测变量的序数logistic回归。
- 采用个体嵌套于国家的多水平混合效应线性回归评估DIF对关联的影响。
主要发现
- 相关DIF(OR>1.1或<0.90)主要见于年龄、性别和工作状态相关的若干HAQ条目。
- 复合HAQ经DIF调整后小幅增加(Δ0.02-0.07),MD-HAQ补偿社会人口学因素相关偏倚最佳(Δ0.02)。
- 回归中所有社会人口学因素仍与DIF调整后HAQ显著相关,系数差异以性别最大(Δ0.02-0.07)但总体可忽略。
关键数值与推荐
- 相关DIF判定标准为OR>1.1或<0.90。
- 复合HAQ经DIF调整后变化幅度为Δ0.02-0.07,MD-HAQ为Δ0.02。
- 回归系数差异以性别最大,为Δ0.02-0.07。
临床怎么用
- 解读HAQ跨社会人口学因素差异时优先选用MD-HAQ。
- 跨性别比较身体功能时对HAQ评分差异应保持谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To investigate potential bias in scores of the Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ) related to socio-demographic (SD) background of patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA). METHODS: Data from the Quantitative Standard Monitoring of Rheumatoid Arthritis study (QUEST-RA), comprising 9022 patients were analysed. Physical function was assessed through 30 items of four HAQ versions: the HAQ-Disability scale, HAQ-II, modified HAQ and multi-dimensional HAQ (MD-HAQ). DIF was investigated using item response theory models implemented in a latent variable modelling framework. Models were equivalent to ordinal logistic regression models with HAQ score (item level) as outcome, the latent trait 'physical function' and individual SD factors (age, gender, education, and employment status) as predictors. Next, scores of composite HAQs were adjusted for DIF. To assess the impact of DIF on associations between SD factors and HAQs, multilevel mixed-effect linear regression models with individuals nested in country were estimated with DIF-adjusted or unadjusted HAQ as outcome. RESULTS: Relevant DIF (OR > 1.1 or <0.90) was found in several HAQ items primarily for age, gender and work status. Adjustment of composite HAQs for DIF resulted in small increases (Δ0.02-0.07); MD-HAQ best compensated for bias related to SD factors (Δ0.02). In regressions, all SD factors remained significantly related to DIF-adjusted HAQs, with differences in coefficients largest for gender (Δ0.02-0.07) but overall negligible. CONCLUSIONS: SD factors produce response bias in individual HAQ items but have little impact on composite HAQs. When interpreting HAQ across SD factors, MD-HAQ is preferred, but caution remains when comparing function across gender.
引用
- Hifinger M, Norton S, Ramiro S, et al. Equivalence in the Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ) across socio-demographic determinants: Analyses within QUEST-RA. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2017. PMID: 28893409. doi:10.1016/j.semarthrit.2017.08.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。