文献速递脊柱关节炎

非训练研究者识别近期炎性背痛患者骶髂关节MRI结构病变的可靠性:DESIR队列结果

What is the reliability of non-trained investigators in recognising structural MRI lesions of sacroiliac joints in patients with recent inflammatory back pain? Results of the DESIR cohort.
PubMed 文献 · RMD Open · 2016-11-11

该研究基于DESIR队列,评估非训练本地读片者识别近期炎性背痛患者骶髂关节MRI结构病变(侵蚀、脂肪病变、强直)与中心读片的一致性。共纳入664例有完整图像的患者,本地与中心读片间总体一致性为「一般」,考虑脂肪病变时提升至「中等」;中心读片阳性率为52.6%,本地读片为35.4%。

要点

  • 本地与中心读片对MRI-SIJ结构病变阳性判定的一致性总体为「一般」,考虑脂肪病变时可达「中等」。
  • 中心读片按至少1个结构病变判定阳性率为52.6%,本地读片按至少单侧「可疑或明确」结构病变为35.4%。
  • 两名中心读片者之间的一致性程度与本地-中心间相似,提示判读可靠性受定义影响。

核心结论

  • 本地与中心读片之间、以及两名中心读片者之间,对结构性MRI-SIJ阳性的判定一致性为一般至中等,考虑脂肪病变时可靠性改善。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于DESIR队列,纳入年龄18-50岁、近期(<3年)且慢性(≥3个月)提示axSpA的炎性背痛患者,共664/708例有完整图像者纳入分析。
  • MRI-SIJ结构病变由非训练本地读片者与两名训练有素的中心读片者分别评分;本地读片者将每侧骶髂关节评为正常、可疑或明确病变,中心读片者分别对每种病变类型评分。
  • 以两名中心读片者评分的均值作为外部标准,计算本地读片(3种阳性定义)与中心读片(9种定义)之间、以及两名中心读片者之间的一致性(κ)。

主要发现

  • 本地与中心读片之间的一致性总体为「一般」,仅在考虑至少2个或3个脂肪病变、以及至少3个侵蚀和/或脂肪病变时一致性为「中等」。
  • 两名中心读片者之间的一致性程度与本地-中心间相似。
  • 按中心读片(至少1个结构病变)MRI-SIJ阳性率为52.6%,按本地读片(至少单侧「可疑」或「明确」结构病变)为35.4%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 本地读片阳性定义包括至少单侧「可疑或明确」结构病变等3种定义;中心读片阳性定义包括至少1个结构病变等9种定义。
  • 一致性评价指标为κ值,一致性等级描述为「一般」至「中等」。

临床怎么用

  • 在临床实践中由非训练读片者判读MRI-SIJ结构病变时,需注意与中心读片的一致性仅为一般至中等,判读结果可能存在差异。
  • 考虑脂肪病变(尤其是至少2个或3个脂肪病变、或至少3个侵蚀和/或脂肪病变)时一致性有所改善,判读时应关注脂肪病变的识别。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to evaluate the reliability of recognising structural lesions on MRI (erosions, fatty lesions, ankylosis) of the sacroiliac joints (MRI-SIJ) in clinical practice compared to a central reading in patients with a possible recent axial spondyloarthritis (axSpA). METHODS: Patients aged 18-50 years, with recent (<3 years) and chronic (≥3 months) inflammatory back pain, suggestive of axSpA were included in the DEvenir des Spondyloarthrites Indifférenciées Récentes (DESIR) cohort. MRI-SIJ structural lesions were scored by non-trained local readers, and by two trained central readers. Local readers scored each SIJ as normal, doubtful or definite lesions. Central readers scored separately each type of lesion. The central reading (mean of the two central readers' scores) was the external standard. Agreement (κ) was calculated first between local (3 definitions of a positive MRI-SIJ) and central readings (9 definitions), and then between the two central readers. RESULTS: 664/708 patients with complete available images were included. Agreements between local and central readings were overall 'fair', except when considering at least 2 or 3 fatty lesions and at least 3 erosions and/or fatty lesions where agreement was 'moderate'. Agreement between central readers was similar. MRI-SIJ was positive for 52.6% of patients according to central reading (at least 1 structural lesion) and for 35.4% of patients according to local reading (at least unilateral 'doubtful' or 'definite' structural lesions). CONCLUSIONS: Agreement on a positive structural MRI-SIJ was fair to moderate between local and central readings, as well as between central readers. The reliability improved when fatty lesions were considered. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCTO 164 8907.

来源:RMD Open,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jacquemin C, Rubio Vargas R, van den Berg R, et al. What is the reliability of non-trained investigators in recognising structural MRI lesions of sacroiliac joints in patients with recent inflammatory back pain? Results of the DESIR cohort. RMD Open. 2016. PMID: 27933207

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。