文献速递脊柱关节炎

银屑病关节炎影像学进展:Ratingen评分与Sharp-van der Heijde法的头对头比较

Radiographic progression in psoriatic arthritis: head-to-head comparison of the Ratingen score and the Sharp-van der Heijde method.
PubMed 文献 · Rheumatology (Oxford) · 2026-01-01

基于比利时银屑病关节炎队列,比较PARS与SVDH的心理测量学性能。两种方法在横断面评分中信度均高,但累积变化信度低且平均进展低于可靠检测阈值,均无法可靠检测低进展队列的累积变化,无明确优劣。

要点

  • PARS与SVDH横断面评分信度高(ICC>0.865),累积变化信度低(ICC约0.48)。
  • 两种方法累积变化反应度中等(SRM:PARS 0.571,SVDH 0.531)。
  • 平均累积变化均小于SDC,提示个体水平可靠检测受限。

核心结论

  • SVDH与PARS在PsA损伤评估中心理测量学性能总体相当,均无明确优势。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于比利时银屑病关节炎(BePas)队列,由两名盲法读者独立对双手足X线片(基线T0、随访T1、T2)分别用SVDH(最高528分)和PARS(最高360分)评分。

主要发现

  • 两种方法均检测到正向平均变化,主要发生在T0至T1之间。
  • 绝对评分者间信度均高(ICC>0.865;基线ICC:PARS 0.906,SVDH 0.888)。
  • 累积变化评分(ΔT2-T0)信度低且相似(ICC:SVDH 0.483,PARS 0.485)。
  • 累积区间反应度中等(两读者平均SRM:PARS 0.571,SVDH 0.531)。
  • 平均累积变化小于SDC(PARS为最高分2.8-3.7%,SVDH为2.8-4.1%),低于个体水平可靠检测阈值。

关键数值与推荐

  • Bland-Altman分析显示PARS在部分比较中绝对一致性界限稍窄,而SVDH经最大可能评分归一化后相对界限更窄。

临床怎么用

  • 临床可用于横断面损伤评估,但解释累积变化需谨慎,低进展人群个体水平变化可能无法可靠检测。

局限性

  • 结论基于低进展队列,向高进展人群推广需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To compare the psychometric properties (inter-rater reliability, agreement, responsiveness and measurement error) of the Psoriatic Arthritis Ratingen Score (PARS) and modified Sharp-van der Heijde (SVDH) methods using the Belgian Psoriatic Arthritis (BePas) cohort. METHODS: Radiographs of hands and feet (baseline T0, follow-ups T1, T2) were independently scored by two blinded readers using SVDH (max 528) and PARS (max 360). Statistical analyses included intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), Bland-Altman analysis, standardized response mean (SRM) and smallest detectable change (SDC). RESULTS: Both methods detected positive mean change, primarily between T0 and T1. Inter-rater reliability for absolute scores was high for both (ICC > 0.865; baseline ICC: PARS 0.906, SVDH 0.888). For cumulative change scores (ΔT2-T0), inter-rater reliability was low and very similar for both methods (ICC = 0.483 for SVDH and 0.485 for PARS). Both methods showed moderate responsiveness over the cumulative interval (two-reader average SRM: PARS 0.571, SVDH 0.531). For both methods and both readers, mean cumulative change scores were smaller than the corresponding SDC values (PARS: 2.8-3.7% of maximum score; SVDH: 2.8-4.1%), indicating that average progression fell below the threshold of reliable individual-level detection. Bland-Altman analysis showed slightly narrower absolute limits of agreement for PARS in selected comparisons, whereas SVDH showed narrower relative limits after normalization to the maximum possible score. CONCLUSION: SVDH and PARS showed broadly comparable psychometric performance for PsA damage assessment. Both methods were robust for cross-sectional scoring but showed important limitations in reliably detecting cumulative change in this low-progression cohort. Neither method demonstrated clear superiority.

来源:Rheumatology (Oxford),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kulyk M, Scriffignano S, Steinfeld S, et al. Radiographic progression in psoriatic arthritis: head-to-head comparison of the Ratingen score and the Sharp-van der Heijde method. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2026. PMID: 42507901. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keag309

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。