文献速递类风湿关节炎

类风湿关节炎滑膜活检标志物观察者间变异性:OMERACT 滑膜活检特别兴趣小组结果

Interobserver variability in synovial tissue biopsy markers in Rheumatoid Arthritis: Results from OMERACT special interest group on synovial tissue biopsy.
PubMed 文献 · Semin Arthritis Rheum · 2026-06-30

该研究评估了跨专家中心对类风湿关节炎滑膜组织活检组织学和免疫组化分析的观察者间一致性,以及观察者经验的影响。来自38例生物制剂初治RA患者的滑膜切片在线评分,初始评分显示免疫标志物一致性较高而血管标志物较低,经改良eDelphi共识采用最大评分法后多数参数一致性改善。

要点

  • 滑膜活检免疫标志物(CD19/20、CD3)观察者间一致性高于血管标志物(FVIII、H&E)。
  • 高经验观察者在特定标志物上的一致性低于低、中等经验观察者。
  • 共识采用最大评分法后多数参数一致性改善,但部分参数仍存在变异性。

核心结论

  • 基于共识的方法可提高跨中心滑膜组织组织学和免疫组化评分的一致性。
  • 采用最大评分法代表了滑膜活检分析标准化的进一步步骤,可能支持其更广泛应用。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究收集了38例生物制剂初治类风湿关节炎患者的滑膜组织切片,染色H&E、FVIII、CD68、CD3和CD19/20并上传至在线平台。
  • 独立观察者采用半定量分析对免疫和血管标志物(0至4分)及Krenn滑膜炎评分(0至9分)进行评分,并记录淋巴聚集和滑膜病理类型。
  • 初始评分后进行改良eDelphi流程以达成共享评分方法共识,随后进行第二次评分,采用Kappa系数评估观察者间一致性。

主要发现

  • 初始评分显示观察者和中心间存在变异性,免疫标志物一致性较高(如CD19/20的kappa=0.737;CD3=0.713),血管标志物较低(FVIII=0.392,H&E=0.316)。
  • 按观察者经验分层显示,高经验观察者在特定标志物上的一致性低于低和中等经验观察者。
  • 经讨论达成采用最大评分法(以切片上可观察到的最高分作为最终评分)的共识后,重新评分显示多数参数观察者间一致性改善(CD68=0.684,Krenn评分=0.545),但某些参数仍存在变异性。

关键数值与推荐

  • 免疫标志物观察者间一致性Kappa系数:CD19/20=0.737,CD3=0.713。
  • 血管标志物观察者间一致性Kappa系数:FVIII=0.392,H&E=0.316。
  • 采用最大评分法重新评分后Kappa系数:CD68=0.684,Krenn评分=0.545。

临床怎么用

  • 跨中心滑膜活检评分应采用共识方法(如最大评分法)以提高观察者间一致性。
  • 免疫标志物评分一致性较高,血管标志物评分需进一步标准化。
  • 观察者经验可能影响评分一致性,需注意培训与校准。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: to evaluate interobserver agreement in synovial tissue (ST) biopsy histology and immunohistochemistry (IHC) analysis across expert centers, and the influence of observers' experience on interobserver agreement. METHODS: ST slides, collected from 38 biologic-naïve rheumatoid arthritis patients, stained for H&E, FVIII, CD68, CD3 and CD19/20, were uploaded to an online platform. Using semiquantitative analysis, independent observers scored ST slides for immune and vascularity markers (0 to 4), and Krenn's synovitis score (0 to 9). Presence of lymphoid aggregates and synovial pathotype were also recorded. After the initial scoring, a modified eDelphi process was conducted to reach consensus on a shared scoring approach among observers, followed by a second scoring. Interobserver agreement was assessed with Kappa coefficients. RESULTS: Initial scoring showed variability across observers and centres, with higher agreement for immune markers (e.g. kappa for CD19/20=0.737; CD3=0.713) compared to vascular ones (FVIII=0.392, H&E = 0.316). Stratifying by observers' experience revealed lower agreement among highly experienced observers compared with low and intermediate-experienced observers on specific markers. After discussion, a modified eDelphi process was conducted, and consensus on adopting a maximum-score approach (the highest score observable on the slide as the final scoring) for semiquantitative parameters was reached. A rescoring exercise, applying this principle, demonstrated improved agreement among observers, across most parameters (CD68= 0.684, Krenn's score 0.545), although variability persists for certain parameters. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that consensus-based methods can improve interobserver agreement in ST histology and IHC scoring across centres. Adoption of a maximum-score approach among observers represents a further step toward standardization of ST biopsy analysis, and may support its broader application STATEMENT OF CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Histological and immunohistochemical analysis of synovial tissue (ST) biopsy is a promising tool in rheumatoid arthritis (RA), both in translational and clinical research. Notably, the differences in ST biopsy evaluation and interpretation persist across different centres of excellence hampers its widespread clinical application and use in multicentre trials. Our study demonstrates that consensus-based approaches, particularly the adoption of a maximum-score principle, can improve interobserver agreement of ST scoring across centres. Our findings represent a critical step toward the standardization of ST biopsy analysis.

来源:Semin Arthritis Rheum,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ferraioli M, Small A, Alivernini S, et al. Interobserver variability in synovial tissue biopsy markers in Rheumatoid Arthritis: Results from OMERACT special interest group on synovial tissue biopsy. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2026. PMID: 42456234. doi:10.1016/j.semarthrit.2026.153041

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。