银屑病关节炎超声基本病变评估的信度及指炎参考图谱的建立
这项多中心横断面研究评估了外周型银屑病关节炎(pPsA)超声基本病变的评估者内和评估者间信度,并分析了标准化培训对信度的影响。研究分三阶段进行网络信度练习,使用Light‘s kappa评估信度,并在第三阶段基于专家共识和病变识别率制定了指炎超声参考图谱。结果显示标准化培训后除指炎外多数病变信度明显改善,第三阶段指炎信度达到中等至良好。
要点
- 标准化培训后滑膜炎、腱鞘炎和附着点炎的评估者内和间信度明显提高。
- 指炎信度在培训后初期改善有限,第三阶段达到中等至良好水平。
- 基于专家共识制定了指炎超声基本病变参考图谱。
核心结论
- 标准化培训与外周型银屑病关节炎超声基本病变评估者内和评估者间信度的显著改善相关。
- 基于共识的超声图谱为识别指炎相关病变提供了实践指导。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心横断面研究,作为APACHE预测队列(NCT03768271)的第一步。
- 2020至2024年间进行三次网络信度练习,使用Light‘s kappa评估信度。
- 来自30个招募中心的经验丰富和受训超声医师参与。
主要发现
- 第一步评估者内kappa:滑膜炎0.50-0.80,腱鞘炎0.51-0.63,附着点炎0.62-0.73,指炎0.31-0.47。
- 第一步评估者间kappa:滑膜炎0.32-0.70,腱鞘炎0.40-0.49,附着点炎0.47-0.60,指炎0.13-0.24。
- 第二步评估者内kappa:滑膜炎0.81-0.90,腱鞘炎0.66-0.83,附着点炎0.61-0.81,指炎0.37-0.47。
- 第二步评估者间kappa:滑膜炎0.72-0.84,腱鞘炎0.55-0.76,附着点炎0.37-0.59,指炎0.12-0.30。
- 第三步指炎评估者内kappa 0.69-0.80,评估者间kappa 0.46-0.68。
关键数值与推荐
- 信度采用Light’s kappa(κ)评估。
- 参考图谱基于专家共识和超声医师间的病变识别率制定。
临床怎么用
- 标准化培训可用于提高外周型银屑病关节炎超声评估的信度。
- 共识超声图谱有助于临床和研究中识别困难的指炎相关病变。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Ultrasound (US) is a valuable tool to detect inflammation in peripheral psoriatic arthritis (pPsA). This multicentre study assessed the intra- and inter-reader reliability of US-detected elementary lesions in peripheral psoriatic arthritis (pPsA) and evaluated the impact of standardized training on reliability, as a first step to guide multicentre assessment in the APACHE cohort. METHODS: A cross-sectional study was conducted to analyse the reliability of pPsA US lesions, as a first step in an ongoing predictive cohort (APACHE, NCT03768271) study. Three web-based reliability exercises were carried out between 2020 and 2024. Inter-rater and intra-rater reliability were assessed using Light's kappa (κ). During the third reliability exercise, a reference atlas of elementary US lesions in dactylitis was developed. RESULTS: Experienced and trainee sonographers from 30 recruiting centres participated into the study. In step 1, intra-reader kappas were moderate-to-good for synovitis (0.50-0.80), tenosynovitis (0.51-0.63), enthesitis (0.62-0.73), and poor for dactylitis (0.31-0.47); inter-reader kappas were lower for synovitis (0.32-0.70), tenosynovitis (0.40-0.49), enthesitis (0.47-0.60) and dactylitis (0.13-0.24). In Step 2, reliability improved notably in expert and trainees except for dactylitis [intra-reader: synovitis (0.81-0.90), tenosynovitis (0.66-0.83), enthesitis (0.61-0.81), dactylitis (0.37-0.47); inter-reader: synovitis c(0.72-0.84), tenosynovitis (0.55-0.76), enthesitis (0.37-0.59), dactylitis (0.12-0.30)]. Step 3 achieved moderate-to-good reliability for dactylitis (intra 0.69-0.80, inter 0.46-0.68). An atlas was produced based on expert consensus and lesion identification rates among sonographers. CONCLUSION: Standardized training was associated with a marked improvement in intra- and inter-reader reliability for the assessment of elementary pPsA lesions. The consensus-based US atlas provides practical guidance for identifying challenging dactylitis-related lesions in clinical and research settings.
引用
- Jousse-Joulin S, D'Agostino MA, Mouterde G, et al. Reliability of ultrasound assessment of elementary lesions in psoriatic arthritis and development of a reference dactylitis atlas. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2026. PMID: 41965075. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keag172
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。