整合分析减少选择偏倚并保持精确度:SPondyloArthritis Caught Early队列影像学结局的2年纵向分析
本研究基于SPondyloArthritis Caught Early队列的轴性脊柱关节炎患者,比较整合分析与仅完成者分析对影像学变化估计精确度的影响,并比较聚合评分与按读者评分模型的差异。结果显示整合分析纳入更多患者且精确度相似,而聚合评分在二分类结局中会低估脊柱变化、高估骶髂关节变化。
要点
- 整合分析较仅完成者分析纳入更多患者且精确度相似。
- 连续结局中聚合评分与按读者评分的变化估计相似。
- 二分类结局中聚合评分低估脊柱变化、高估骶髂关节变化。
核心结论
- 多水平模型通过整合患者、时间点、读者和轮次的信息,保留水平变异性,从而减少选择偏倚并提高变化估计的精确度。
研究设计与样本
- 基于SPondyloArthritis Caught Early队列的轴性脊柱关节炎患者,随访2年,骶髂关节和脊柱影像由≥2名中心读者分两轮评分,使用广义估计方程分析影像学结局变化。
主要发现
- 整合分析纳入332例患者,仅完成者分析纳入279例。
- 与多水平仅完成者分析相比,整合分析纳入的患者多12%-16%,精确度相似。
- 在仅完成者人群中,连续结局的聚合评分与按读者评分模型的变化估计相似。
- 在二分类结局中,聚合评分模型低估脊柱变化(最大少82%)并高估骶髂关节变化(最大多37%)。
临床怎么用
- 在影像学纵向分析中,可考虑采用整合分析或多水平模型以减少选择偏倚并保持精确度。
- 使用聚合评分分析二分类结局时需注意其可能低估脊柱变化、高估骶髂关节变化。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cohort studies often use simple models, for example, completers-only or aggregated scores, to assess changes in imaging outcomes. With more data available, this introduces selection bias. Integrated analyses allow scores from multiple reading rounds; therefore, we assessed their effect on the change estimates' precision compared with the completers-only analysis. Second, we compared change estimates from models using aggregated scores and scores analysed per reader. METHODS: Patients with axial spondyloarthritis (axSpA) from the SPondyloArthritis Caught Early cohort were followed for 2 years. Imaging of the sacroiliac joints and spine was scored by ≥2 central readers in two rounds. Change in imaging outcomes was analysed using generalised estimating equations, with different patient and data selections for integrated and completers-only analyses. The integrated and multilevel completers-only analyses assessed outcomes per reader. Change estimates of the completers-only analysis of aggregated scores of readers were compared with estimates of the multilevel completers-only analysis. RESULTS: The integrated analysis included 332 patients (vs 279 completers-only). Compared with the multilevel completers-only analysis, the integrated analysis included 12%-16% more patients with a similar precision. Within the completers-only population, change estimates from models using reader and aggregated scores were similar for continuous outcomes. However, similar comparisons in dichotomous outcomes showed that models with aggregated scores underestimated spinal changes (maximum 82% less) and overestimated sacroiliac joint changes (maximum 37% more). CONCLUSION: Multilevel models retain level variability by integrating information across patients, time points, readers and rounds to reduce selection bias and improve precision of change, which would otherwise be lost in simpler models.
引用
- de Bruin LJE, van Gaalen FA, de Hooge M, et al. Reducing selection bias while maintaining precision through an integrated analysis: 2-year longitudinal analysis of imaging outcomes in the SPondyloArthritis Caught Early cohort. RMD Open. 2026. PMID: 41887720. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2025-006634
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。