机器人超声与AI驱动滑膜炎评估在类风湿关节炎中的诊断效能与可靠性:ARTHUR对照试验结果
ARTHUR对照试验纳入20名健康对照和29例RA患者,评估AI驱动的机器人超声(RUS)与训练有素风湿科医生操作的人工超声(HUS)评估手部滑膜炎的可靠性和诊断效能。RUS在RA患者中的机器人内信度中等至良好(GS ICC 0.65,CD ICC 0.86),人机一致性中等(GS ICC 0.59,CD ICC 0.64);RUS检测临床关节炎的诊断准确率为59%。
要点
- RUS在RA患者中机器人内信度中等至良好:GS ICC 0.65,CD ICC 0.86。
- RUS与HUS人机一致性中等:GS ICC 0.59,CD ICC 0.64。
- RUS检测临床关节炎的诊断准确率为59%。
核心结论
- RUS与HUS在评估RA手部滑膜炎方面总体一致性中等至良好,但关节水平一致性低,尤其MCP关节,影响了诊断效能。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入20名健康对照和29例符合DMARD起始或强化治疗条件且手部至少一个临床肿胀关节的RA患者。
- 超声机器人对对照和患者进行两次无间隔扫描,HUS进行一次扫描。
- RUS(使用AI软件)和HUS按照EULAR-OMERACT评分系统对GS和CD进行0-3分滑膜炎评分(范围0-66)。
- 评估机器人内及人机信度和一致性,并以临床关节炎诊断为参考评估RUS检测关节炎的诊断效能。
主要发现
- RA患者中机器人内信度中等至良好,ICC值GS为0.65,CD为0.86。
- 人机一致性中等,ICC值GS为0.59,CD为0.64。
- 关节水平上,RUS在MCP关节获得的评分高于HUS,其他关节组评分相当。
- RUS检测临床检测到的关节炎的诊断准确率为59%。
关键数值与推荐
- 滑膜炎评分采用EULAR-OMERACT评分系统,GS和CD各0-3分,总分范围0-66。
- 机器人内信度ICC:RA患者GS 0.65,CD 0.86。
- 人机一致性ICC:GS 0.59,CD 0.64。
- RUS诊断准确率59%。
临床怎么用
- RUS与HUS总体一致性中等至良好,但关节水平一致性低,尤其MCP关节,影响诊断效能。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To evaluate the reliability and diagnostic performance of artificial intelligence (AI) driven robotic ultrasonography (RUS) compared with human ultrasonography (HUS) performed by a trained rheumatologist for assessing synovitis in the hands of healthy controls and patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA). METHODS: 20 healthy controls and 29 patients with RA eligible for initiation or intensification of disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs, with at least one clinically swollen joint in the hands, were included. The ultrasound robot scanned controls and patients twice without interval, whereas HUS was performed once. Synovitis was scored from 0 to 3 for Greyscale (GS) and Doppler (CD) by RUS (using AI software) and HUS according to the European League Against Rheumatism-OMERACT scoring system (range 0-66).Intrarobot and human-robot reliability and agreement were assessed. Furthermore, the diagnostic performance of RUS for detecting arthritis was evaluated using the clinical arthritis diagnosis as reference. RESULTS: Intrarobot reliability was moderate to good, with intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) values of 0.65 (GS) and 0.86 (CD) in patients with RA. Human-robot agreement was moderate, with ICCs of 0.59 (GS) and 0.64 (CD). At joint level, RUS obtained higher scores for MCP joints than HUS, while scores were comparable for other joint groups. The diagnostic accuracy of RUS for detecting clinically-detected arthritis was 59%. CONCLUSION: A moderate to good overall agreement was seen between RUS and HUS in assessing synovitis in RA hands. However, at the joint level, low agreement was observed, particularly for MCP joints in both intrarobot and human-robot comparisons, which affected diagnostic performance.
引用
- Ammitzbøll-Danielsen M, Østergaard M, Tamm L, et al. Diagnostic performance and reliability of robotic ultrasonography and artificial intelligence-driven synovitis assessment in rheumatoid arthritis: results from the Controlled ARTHUR Trial. RMD Open. 2025. PMID: 41219128. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2025-006099
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。