使用简化侵蚀狭窄评分或Sharp/van der Heijde评分对类风湿关节炎临床试验检测影像学进展差异效能的影响
研究利用DRESS和BeSt两项类风湿关节炎临床试验数据,从Sharp/van der Heijde评分(SHS)推导出简化侵蚀狭窄评分(SENS),评估SENS与SHS的效标效度及检测组间影像学进展差异的效能。SENS与SHS的Spearman相关系数均>0.9(DRESS研究18个月变化评分例外为0.787),SENS较SHS的效能损失最多为19%(BeSt第5年),且效能水平越高两者差异越小。结论认为SENS似乎是SHS的合理替代方案,仅伴随有限的检测组间影像学进展差异的效能损失。
要点
- SENS与SHS的效标效度相关系数均>0.9(DRESS研究18个月变化评分例外为0.787)。
- SENS较SHS的效能损失最多为19%(BeSt第5年)。
- SENS与SHS的效能差异在较高效能水平时更小。
核心结论
- SENS似乎是SHS的合理替代方案,仅伴随有限的检测组间影像学进展差异的效能损失。
研究设计与样本
- 利用DRESS和BeSt两项类风湿关节炎临床试验数据,从SHS推导出SENS。
- 通过计算Spearman相关系数评估SENS相对SHS的效标效度。
- 采用bootstrapping为每项研究生成10 000次重复,比较两种评分检测组间差异的效能。
- 比较各重复中进展差异显著(使用协方差分析校正基线评分)的重复数。
主要发现
- SENS与SHS的相关系数均>0.9,表明SENS相对作为参考标准的SHS具有高效标效度。
- DRESS研究18个月变化评分的相关系数略低(0.787)。
- SENS较SHS的效能损失最多为19%(BeSt第5年)。
- SENS与SHS的效能差异在较高效能水平时更小。
关键数值与推荐
- SENS与SHS的Spearman相关系数均>0.9(DRESS研究18个月变化评分例外为0.787)。
- SENS较SHS的效能损失最多为19%(BeSt第5年)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The Simple Erosion Narrowing Score (SENS) is a simplification of the Sharp/van der Heijde score (SHS). Previous studies found SENS and SHS to have very similar measurement properties, but suggest that SENS has a lower discriminative ability that may result in reduced power. Therefore, we aimed to quantify the effect of using SENS rather than SHS on the power to show between-group differences in radiographic progression. METHODS: Using data from two clinical trials in RA (DRESS and BeSt), SENS was derived from the SHS. Criterion validity of the SENS in relation to the SHS was assessed by calculating the Spearman correlation. The power of both scores to show a difference between groups was compared using bootstrapping to generate 10 000 replications of each study. Then, the number of replications with a significant difference in progression (using analysis of covariance adjusted for baseline scores) were compared. RESULTS: Correlations between SENS and SHS were all >0.9, indicating high criterion validity of SENS compared with SHS as a reference standard. There was one exception-the DRESS study showed a somewhat lower correlation for the change score at 18 months (0.787). The loss in power of SENS over SHS was limited to at most 19% (BeSt year 5). In addition, the difference in power between SENS and SHS is smaller at higher levels of power. CONCLUSION: SENS appears to be a reasonable alternative to SHS, with only a limited loss of power to show between-group differences in radiographic progression.
引用
- den Broeder N, Bolhuis TE, van Herwaarden N, et al. Effect of using the Simple Erosion Narrowing Score or Sharp/van der Heijde score on the power of rheumatoid arthritis clinical trials to detect differences in radiographic progression. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2025. PMID: 38867707. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keae328
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。