评估定性研究方法学质量及证据分级以形成临床建议的现有指南综述:一项系统文献综述
该系统综述检索多个数据库至2020年10月23日,共纳入15篇文献,评估定性研究方法学质量及证据分级的现有指南。结果发现6篇描述方法学工具、7篇描述一种关注四个关键组成部分的方法、2篇关注基于定性证据的临床建议分级;作者认为目前对于适用工具、清单和方法缺乏共识。
要点
- 共纳入15篇文献,其中6篇描述评估定性研究质量的方法学工具。
- 7篇描述一种关注四个关键组成部分的方法,用于判断对定性研究系统评价结果的信心。
- 2篇关注基于定性证据的临床建议分级,分别描述定性证据等级和研究金字塔。
核心结论
- 目前对于适用于评估定性研究方法学质量和定性证据分级以指导临床实践的工具、清单和方法缺乏共识。
- 作者认为本工作有望促进将定性证据纳入EULAR层面制定建议的过程。
研究设计与样本
- 系统文献综述,检索PubMed/Medline、EMBASE、Web of Science、COCHRANE和PsycINFO数据库,从建库至2020年10月23日。
- 纳入英文原始文章和指南文件,描述定性研究方法学质量评估工具的开发、应用或指南,以及定性证据分级指南。
- 共检索到9073条记录,51篇进入全文审阅,最终纳入15篇。
- 采用叙述性综合方法识别纳入研究之间的关键相似点。
主要发现
- 6篇文章描述评估定性研究质量的方法学工具,评估研究设计、招募、伦理严谨性、数据收集和分析。
- 7篇文章描述一种方法,关注四个关键组成部分以确定对定性研究系统评价结果的信心程度。
- 2篇文章关注基于定性证据的临床建议分级,其中一篇描述定性证据等级,另一篇描述研究金字塔。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To understand (1) what guidance exists to assess the methodological quality of qualitative research; (2) what methods exist to grade levels of evidence from qualitative research to inform recommendations within European Alliance of Associations for Rheumatology (EULAR). METHODS: A systematic literature review was performed in multiple databases including PubMed/Medline, EMBASE, Web of Science, COCHRANE and PsycINFO, from inception to 23 October 2020. Eligible studies included primary articles and guideline documents available in English, describing the: (1) development; (2) application of validated tools (eg, checklists); (3) guidance on assessing methodological quality of qualitative research and (4) guidance on grading levels of qualitative evidence. A narrative synthesis was conducted to identify key similarities between included studies. RESULTS: Of 9073 records retrieved, 51 went through to full-manuscript review, with 15 selected for inclusion. Six articles described methodological tools to assess the quality of qualitative research. The tools evaluated research design, recruitment, ethical rigour, data collection and analysis. Seven articles described one approach, focusing on four key components to determine how much confidence to place in findings from systematic reviews of qualitative research. Two articles focused on grading levels of clinical recommendations based on qualitative evidence; one described a qualitative evidence hierarchy, and another a research pyramid. CONCLUSION: There is a lack of consensus on the use of tools, checklists and approaches suitable for appraising the methodological quality of qualitative research and the grading of qualitative evidence to inform clinical practice. This work is expected to facilitate the inclusion of qualitative evidence in the process of developing recommendations at EULAR level.
引用
- Sekhon M, de Thurah A, Fragoulis GE, et al. Synthesis of guidance available for assessing methodological quality and grading of evidence from qualitative research to inform clinical recommendations: a systematic literature review. RMD Open. 2024. PMID: 38886002. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2023-004032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。