骨盆常规X线附着点病变评估:骶髂关节炎之外诊断脊柱关节炎的另一工具
研究纳入111例脊柱关节炎(SpA)患者与50例无SpA的慢性腰痛对照,采用骨盆X线附着点放射学指数(REI,分三个区域0-3级评分)由三名盲法观察者各评估三次。结果显示REI在SpA诊断中的敏感度为82%,而X线骶髂关节炎敏感度为38.7%;无X线骶髂关节炎的SpA患者中75%为REI阳性。作者认为REI可能有助于SpA诊断。
要点
- REI对SpA诊断的敏感度为82%,X线骶髂关节炎的敏感度为38.7%。
- 无X线骶髂关节炎的SpA患者中75%为REI阳性。
- 总REI、III区与I区诊断效能最高,观察者间一致性几乎完美。
核心结论
- 采用骨盆X线REI评估骨盆附着点可能有助于SpA诊断,总REI、III区和I区准确度最高且信度几乎完美,对影像学无骶髂关节炎的患者尤其有帮助。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入SpA患者与无SpA的慢性腰痛对照组,三名盲法观察者各对每张骨盆X线评估三次。
- REI按三个区域评分:I区为耻骨上支,II区为耻骨联合,III区为坐耻支;分级为0-3级,三区结果之和为总REI。
- 采用经患病率与偏倚校正的加权kappa统计量,即Gwet一致性系数进行统计分析。
主要发现
- 共纳入161例患者,其中111例为SpA(39.6%为中轴型SpA,47.7%为外周型SpA),50例无SpA。
- SpA组III区REI 2级和3级分别占36.7%和25.7%,对照组仅6%具有这些分级。
- I区1至3级在SpA组的总频率为42.3%(分别为8.1%、14.4%和19.8%),对照组仅2%。
- II区在多数SpA患者(82.9%)和对照组(98%)中未受累;对照组三个区域均以0级最常见。
- ROC曲线分析显示诊断效能最高的为总REI、III区和I区。
关键数值与推荐
- REI分级:0级正常;1级轻微改变(皮质下骨矿物质脱失和/或骨膜须状改变,表现为肌腱附着处皮质骨的透亮区和骨小梁化);2级破坏性改变(1级表现加附着点处骨侵蚀);3级为2级表现加皮质骨外>2 mm的须状改变。
- REI对SpA诊断的敏感度为82%,X线骶髂关节炎的敏感度为38.7%。
- 无X线骶髂关节炎的SpA患者中75%为REI阳性。
- 各区域及独立阅片者之间的一致性几乎完美。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,采用骨盆X线REI评估骨盆附着点可能有助于SpA诊断,尤其对影像学无骶髂关节炎的患者有帮助。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION/OBJECTIVES: Enthesitis is a cardinal feature of spondylarthritis (SpA), and the pelvis is a common site of enthesitis. This study aimed to establish the association between pelvic enthesis involvement on pelvic X-ray and SpA diagnosis through a radiographic enthesis index (REI) and to assess the reliability and accuracy of this REI. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The participants were SpA patients and a control group composed of patients with chronic lumbar pain without SpA. Three blinded observers assessed each pelvic radiography three times. Three zones were used: Zone I (ZI), the iliopubic ramus; Zone II (ZII), the pubic symphysis, and Zone III (ZIII), the ischiopubic ramus. A grading system was created from 0 to 3 [Grade 0, normal; Grade 1, minimal changes (subcortical bone demineralization and/or periosteal wishkering, seen as radiolucency and trabeculation of the cortical bone upon tendon insertion); Grade 2, destructive changes (Grade 1 findings and erosions at the enthesis site); and Grade 3, findings of Grade 2 plus >2 mm whiskering out of the cortical bone) for the REI. The sum of the results of the three zones was called the total REI. For statistical analysis, we used the weighted kappa statistic adjusted for prevalence and bias using Gwet's agreement coefficient. RESULTS: We enrolled 161 patients, 111 of them with SpA (39.6 % with axial SpA and 47.7 % with peripheral SpA) and 50 without SpA. In the SpA group, 36.7 % and 25.7 % had REI Grades 2 and 3 in ZIII, respectively, while only 6 % of the controls had these grades. For ZI, the frequency of Grades 1 to 3 was 42.3 % in the SpA group (8.1 %, 14.4 %, and 19.8 %, respectively), compared to only 2 % in the controls. ZII was unaffected in most of the patients with SpA (82.9 %) and in the controls (98 %). In the control group, Grade 0 was the most common REI grade in all three zones. The agreement was almost perfect for each zone and between the independent readers. The ROC-curve analysis showed that the highest performance areas were the total REI, ZIII, and ZI. Most (75 %) of the SpA patients without sacroiliitis on X-ray were REI-positive. The sensitivity of the REI for SpA diagnosis was 82 %, while the sensitivity of sacroiliitis on X-ray was 38.7 %. CONCLUSIONS: The assessment of pelvic enthesis using the REI on pelvic radiography may be useful for SpA diagnosis. Total REI, ZIII, and ZI had the highest accuracy and almost perfect reliability. The REI is especially helpful in patients without sacroiliitis on imaging.
引用
- Enrique CP, María SA, Gustavo RS, et al. Assessment of enthesopathy in conventional pelvis radiography: Another tool for spondyloarthritis diagnosis beyond sacroiliitis. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2024. PMID: 38642418. doi:10.1016/j.semarthrit.2024.152435
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。