CAPI评分:一种用于识别甲襞视频毛细血管镜疾病模式的定量算法
本研究对851份甲襞视频毛细血管镜(NVC)样本(21 957张图像)进行软件分析,构建了包含四条规则的CAPI评分算法,用于区分系统性硬化症(SSc)与非SSc模式、SSc早期/活动期/晚期以及非SSc正常/非特异性模式,各规则准确率分别为0.88、0.82和0.73。
要点
- CAPI评分算法基于毛细血管密度及异常毛细血管、巨大毛细血管、迂曲和出血百分比设定切点。
- 规则1区分SSc与非SSc模式,准确率0.88;规则2和3区分SSc早期、活动期与晚期,准确率0.82。
- 规则4区分非SSc正常与非特异性模式,准确率0.73;当分析限于观察者间完全共识的NVC时准确率提高。
核心结论
- CAPI评分算法可能成为克服主观性局限、有助于分配疾病模式的工具。
研究设计与样本
- 由9名毛细血管镜医师检查NVC,对疾病模式达成共识(3名观察者中至少2名一致)的NVC使用内部开发软件进行分析。
- 共对851份NVC(21 957张图像)进行了软件分析,这些NVC的疾病模式均已达成共识。
主要发现
- 为毛细血管密度以及异常毛细血管、巨大毛细血管、迂曲和出血的百分比设定适当切点,可实现疾病模式分类并开发CAPI评分算法。
- CAPI评分算法包含四条规则:规则1区分SSc与非SSc,准确率0.88;规则2和3区分SSc早期与SSc活动期与SSc晚期,准确率0.82;规则4区分非SSc正常与非SSc非特异性,准确率0.73。
- 当分析仅限于观察者间对疾病模式达成完全共识的NVC时,准确率提高。
关键数值与推荐
- 规则1(SSc vs 非SSc)准确率0.88。
- 规则2和3(SSc早期 vs SSc活动期 vs SSc晚期)准确率0.82。
- 规则4(非SSc正常 vs 非SSc非特异性)准确率0.73。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 毛细血管镜医师之间的主观性仍是一个局限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: EULAR supports the use of nailfold videocapillaroscopy (NVC) for identifying disease patterns (DPs) associated with SSc and RP. Recently, EULAR proposed an easy-to-manage procedure, a so-called Fast Track algorithm, for differentiating SSc patterns from non-SSc patterns in NVC specimens. However, subjectivity among capillaroscopists remains a limitation. Our aim was to perform a software-based analysis of NVC peculiarities in a cohort of samples from SSc and RP patients and, subsequently, build a Fast Track-inspired algorithm for identifying DPs without the constraint of interobserver variability. METHODS: NVCs were examined by 9 capillaroscopists. Those NVCs whose DPs were consensually agreed upon (by ≥2 out of 3 interobservers) were subsequently analysed using in-house-developed software. The results for each variable were grouped according to the consensually agreed-upon DPs in order to identify useful hallmarks for categorizing them. RESULTS: A total of 851 NVCs (21 957 images) whose DPs had been consensually agreed upon were software-analysed. Appropriate cut-offs set for capillary density and percentage of abnormal and giant capillaries, tortuosities and haemorrhages allowed DP categorization and the development of the CAPI-score algorithm. This consisted of four rules: Rule 1, SSc vs non-SSc, accuracy 0.88; Rules 2 and 3, SSc-early vs SSc-active vs SSc-late, accuracy 0.82; Rule 4, non-SSc normal vs non-SSc non-specific, accuracy 0.73. Accuracy improved when the analysis was limited to NVCs whose DPs had achieved full consensus between the interobservers. CONCLUSION: The CAPI-score algorithm may become a tool that is useful in assigning DPs by overcoming the limitations of subjectivity.
引用
- Gracia Tello BDC, Sáez Comet L, Lledó G, et al. Capi-score: a quantitative algorithm for identifying disease patterns in nailfold videocapillaroscopy. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2024. PMID: 38530791. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keae197
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。