中轴型脊柱关节炎的影像学学习:不仅仅是经验问题
该事后分析纳入163例下背痛受试者(89例中轴型脊柱关节炎,74例其他疾病),由9名盲法阅片者分三组经验水平对X线、CT和MRI进行评估。结果显示经验最丰富组诊断效能最高(MRI 85.9%),无经验和半经验组CT与MRI诊断效能最高(分别为78.5%和85.3%),MRI在无经验与有经验组间差异最大(76.1% vs 85.9%,p=0.001)。
要点
- 经验最丰富组MRI诊断效能最高(85.9%),CT在经验丰富组阅片者间一致性最佳(κ=0.87)。
- 无经验和半经验组中CT与MRI诊断效能最高(分别为78.5%和85.3%)。
- MRI在无经验与有经验组间诊断效能差异最大(76.1% vs 85.9%,p=0.001)。
核心结论
- 不同影像 modality 对中轴型脊柱关节炎诊断的可学习性存在差异,MRI需要更多经验,而CT更适合经验不足的放射科医生。
- 诊断依赖临床和影像信息两者结合。
研究设计与样本
- 事后分析,纳入163例下背痛受试者,其中89例中轴型脊柱关节炎、74例其他疾病(机械性、退行性或非特异性下背痛)。
- 最终诊断由一位经验丰富的风湿免疫科医生在阅片前确立。
- 9名盲法阅片者分为三组不同经验水平,对骶髂关节X线、CT和MRI评分判断中轴型脊柱关节炎存在与否。
- 诊断效能参数通过列联表计算,阅片者组间诊断效能差异用McNemar检验评估,阅片者间信度用Fleiss kappa评估。
主要发现
- 除X线外,经验最丰富组诊断效能最高。
- 无经验和半经验组中CT与MRI诊断效能最高(分别为78.5%和85.3%)。
- 经验丰富组中MRI诊断效能最高(85.9%)。
- MRI在无经验与有经验组间诊断效能差异最大(76.1% vs 85.9%,p=0.001)。
- 经验丰富组CT的阅片者间一致性最佳(κ=0.87)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Reliable interpretation of imaging findings is essential for the diagnosis of axial spondyloarthritis (axSpA) and requires a high level of experience. We investigated experience-dependent differences in diagnostic accuracies using X-ray (XR), MRI and CT. METHODS: This post hoc analysis included 163 subjects with low back pain. Eighty-nine patients had axSpA, and 74 patients had other conditions (mechanical, degenerative or non-specific low back pain). Final diagnoses were established by an experienced rheumatologist before the reading sessions. Nine blinded readers (divided into three groups with different levels of experience) scored the XR, CT and MRI of the sacroiliac joints for the presence versus absence of axSpA. Parameters for diagnostic performance were calculated using contingency tables. Differences in diagnostic performance between the reader groups were assessed using the McNemar test. Inter-rater reliability was assessed using Fleiss kappa. RESULTS: Diagnostic performance was highest for the most experienced reader group, except for XR. In the inexperienced and semi-experienced group, diagnostic performance was highest for CT&MRI (78.5% and 85.3%, respectively). In the experienced group, MRI showed the highest performance (85.9%). The greatest difference in diagnostic performance was found for MRI between the inexperienced and experienced group (76.1% vs 85.9%, p=0.001). Inter-rater agreement was best for CT in the experienced group with κ=0.87. CONCLUSION: Differences exist in the learnability of the imaging modalities for axSpA diagnosis. MRI requires more experience, while CT is more suitable for inexperienced radiologists. However, diagnosis relies on both clinical and imaging information.
引用
- Radny F, Ziegeler K, Eshed I, et al. Learning imaging in axial spondyloarthritis: more than just a matter of experience. RMD Open. 2024. PMID: 38443089. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2023-003944
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。