三种银屑病关节炎筛查问卷在初级保健监测研究中的性能比较
本研究在初级保健银屑病监测中比较PEST、CONTEST和CONTESTjt三种患者自填筛查问卷的性能。791名参与者中48例诊断为银屑病关节炎;三种问卷敏感性0.542-0.625、特异性0.757-0.834,ROC曲线下面积相似,结果未提示某一问卷更优。
要点
- 791名参与者中48例诊断为银屑病关节炎。
- PEST敏感性0.625、特异性0.757;CONTEST敏感性0.604、特异性0.768;CONTESTjt敏感性0.542、特异性0.834。
- CONTESTjt特异性略优于PEST,但三种问卷ROC曲线下面积相似,未提示首选问卷。
核心结论
- 本研究中三种筛查问卷之间差异极小,结果未提示某一问卷更优。
- 选择哪种工具将取决于其他因素,如简便性和患者负担低。
研究设计与样本
- 从全科诊所数据库识别已知无银屑病关节炎的银屑病患者,邀请至二级保健中心接受临床评估。
- 参与者完成PEST、CONTEST和CONTESTjt三种患者自填筛查问卷及其他患者报告指标,并接受皮肤和关节临床检查。
- 有提示银屑病关节炎的炎症性关节炎体征者经全科医生转诊至二级保健风湿科门诊进一步评估。
- 791名参与者参加筛查访视,165名被判定有炎症性关节炎体征和症状,其中150名被转诊评估,126名被接诊,48名诊断为银屑病关节炎。
主要发现
- PEST:敏感性0.625(95%CI 0.482, 0.749),特异性0.757(95%CI 0.724, 0.787)。
- CONTEST:敏感性0.604(95%CI 0.461, 0.731),特异性0.768(95%CI 0.736, 0.798)。
- CONTESTjt:敏感性0.542(95%CI 0.401, 0.676),特异性0.834(95%CI 0.805, 0.859)。
- CONTESTjt特异性略优于PEST,但三种工具的ROC曲线下面积相似。
关键数值与推荐
- PEST敏感性0.625(95%CI 0.482, 0.749),特异性0.757(95%CI 0.724, 0.787)。
- CONTEST敏感性0.604(95%CI 0.461, 0.731),特异性0.768(95%CI 0.736, 0.798)。
- CONTESTjt敏感性0.542(95%CI 0.401, 0.676),特异性0.834(95%CI 0.805, 0.859)。
- 三种问卷的ROC曲线下面积相似。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to compare the performance of three PsA screening questionnaires in a primary care psoriasis surveillance study. METHODS: Participants with psoriasis, and not known to have PsA, were identified from general practice databases and invited to attend a secondary care centre for a clinical assessment. The three patient-completed screening questionnaires (PEST, CONTEST and CONTESTjt) were administered, along with other patient-reported measures, and a clinical examination of skin and joints was performed. Participants who demonstrated signs of inflammatory arthritis suggestive of PsA were referred, via their GP, for a further assessment in a secondary care rheumatology clinic. RESULTS: A total of 791 participants attended the screening visit, and 165 participants were judged to have signs and symptoms of inflammatory arthritis, of which 150 were referred for assessment. Of these, 126 were seen and 48 were diagnosed with PsA. The results for each questionnaire were as follows: PEST: sensitivity 0.625 (95% CI 0.482, 0.749), specificity 0.757 (0.724, 0.787); CONTEST: sensitivity 0.604 (0.461, 0.731), specificity 0.768 (0.736, 0.798); and CONTESTjt: sensitivity 0.542 (0.401, 0.676), specificity 0.834 (0.805, 0.859). CONTESTjt demonstrated marginally superior specificity to PEST, though the area under the ROC curve was similar for all three instruments. CONCLUSION: Minimal differences between the three screening questionnaires were found in this study, and no preferred questionnaire is indicated by these results. The choice of which instrument to choose will depend on other factors, such as simplicity and low patient burden.
引用
- Helliwell PS, Coates LC, Ransom M, et al. The comparative performance of three screening questionnaires for psoriatic arthritis in a primary care surveillance study. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2024. PMID: 37341637. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/kead310
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。