类风湿关节炎影像学进展的稳健分析方法
该研究通过模拟比较随机系数模型、线性外推插补的协方差分析及末次观测值结转插补的协方差分析在类风湿关节炎影像学进展分析中的表现,显示随机系数模型在偏倚、均方根误差、功效和I类错误率方面均优于线性外推插补的协方差分析,推荐随机系数模型作为主要分析方法,线性外推插补的协方差分析作为敏感性分析。
要点
- 随机系数模型在偏倚、均方根误差、功效和I类错误率方面优于线性外推插补的协方差分析。
- 无缺失数据时,协方差分析与随机系数模型性能相似。
- 有缺失数据时,随机系数模型+观测值在功效和偏倚方面相似或优于线性外推插补的协方差分析。
核心结论
- 模拟支持随机系数模型是线性外推插补的协方差分析更敏感且更精确的替代方法,用于长期扩展研究和儿科研究中mTSS的主要分析。
- 随机系数模型可通过估计斜率(时间每变化一个单位时mTSS的变化)为有缺失数据的时间点提供参考。
- 推荐线性外推插补的协方差分析作为敏感性分析。
研究设计与样本
- 考虑双臂(活性治疗和安慰剂)设置,研究周期为44周。
- 在不同场景下比较随机系数模型、线性外推插补的协方差分析和末次观测值结转插补的协方差分析在偏倚、均方根误差、功效和I类错误率方面的表现。
主要发现
- 在评估的场景下,随机系数模型在偏倚、均方根误差、功效和I类错误率指标上优于线性外推插补的协方差分析。
- 无缺失数据时,协方差分析和随机系数模型提供相似性能。
- 有缺失数据时,随机系数模型+观测值在功效和偏倚方面提供与线性外推插补的协方差分析相似或更好的结果。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为随机系数模型可作为长期扩展研究和儿科研究中mTSS的主要分析方法,这些研究缺失数据可能性更高。
- 作者推荐线性外推插补的协方差分析作为敏感性分析。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Demonstrating inhibition of the structural damage to joints as a statistically significant difference in radiographic progression as measured by the van der Heijde modified Total Sharp Score (mTSS) is a common objective in trials for rheumatoid arthritis treatments. The frequently used analysis of the covariance model with missing data imputed using linear extrapolation (analyses of covariance, ANCOVA+LE) may not be ideal for long-term extension studies or for paediatric studies. The random coefficient (RC) model may represent a better alternative.A two-arm (active treatment and placebo) setting with a week 44 study period was considered. RC model, ANCOVA+LE and ANCOVA with last observation carried forward imputation were compared under different scenarios in bias, root mean square error (RMSE), power and type I error rate.The RC model outperformed ANCOVA+LE in metrics measuring bias, RMSE, power and type I error rate under the evaluated scenarios. ANCOVA and RC provide similar performance when there are no missing data. With missing data, RC+observed (OBS) provides similar or better results than ANCOVA+LE in power and bias.Our simulations support that RC is both a more sensitive and a more precise alternative to the commonly used ANCOVA+LE as a primary method for analysing mTSS in long-term extension and paediatric studies with a higher likelihood of missing data. The RC model can provide a reference at time points with missing data by estimating a slope; mTSS change by one unit change in time. ANCOVA+LE is recommended as a sensitivity analysis.
引用
- Landewé R, Sun L, Chen YF, et al. Robust analyses for radiographic progression in rheumatoid arthritis. RMD Open. 2023. PMID: 37015757. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2022-002543
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。