一项国际德尔菲练习以确定测量ANCA相关血管炎治疗反应的重要项目
该国际三回合在线德尔菲练习纳入89例ANCA相关血管炎(AAV)患者和176名专科医生,对评估治疗反应各项目的重要性按1-9分评分,≥70%参与者评为7-9分视为高度重要。结果显示患者与医生在疾病活动度、死亡率和患者报告结局等多个项目上达成共识,但部分项目仅被患者或仅被医生高度评价。这些数据将用于指导AAV治疗反应评估标准的后续制定。
要点
- 患者与医生共同高度评价疾病活动度、死亡率和患者报告结局项目。
- 仅医生高度评价达到特定BVAS评分;仅患者高度评价尿液分析变化、急性期反应物、疼痛和疲劳。
- 损害和不良事件相关项目被两组均高度评价。
核心结论
- 患者与医生在评估AAV治疗反应的许多重要项目上存在共识,但部分项目仅被患者或仅被医生认为重要,这些数据将用于指导治疗反应评估标准的后续制定。
研究设计与样本
- 国际三回合在线德尔菲练习,参与者包括AAV患者和具有AAV专长的医生。
- 89例患者和176名医生完成了三回合德尔菲练习。
- 参与者按1-9分对每个项目在评估AAV治疗反应时的重要性进行评分。
主要发现
- 高度评价的项目涉及疾病活动度(器官受累范围、医生整体评估)、死亡率(生存)和患者报告结局(患者整体评估和健康相关生活质量测量)。
- 达到特定BVAS评分仅被医生高度评价。
- 仅被患者高度评价的项目包括实验室指标(尿液分析变化和急性期反应物)、疼痛和疲劳。
- 损害和不良事件相关项目被两组均高度评价。
关键数值与推荐
- 项目被≥70%参与者评为7-9分视为高度重要。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: ANCA-associated vasculitis (AAV) is characterized by fluctuating levels of disease activity, but no formal criteria exist to measure response to treatment. This Delphi exercise aimed to reach consensus about which measures are considered by patients and physicians to be most important when assessing response to treatment in clinical trials of AAV. METHODS: An international 3-round online Delphi exercise was conducted. Survey participants included patients with AAV and physicians with expertise in AAV. Survey participants were asked to rate (on a scale of 1-9) the importance of each item when assessing response to treatment in AAV. Items scored 7-9 by ≥70% participants were considered highly important. RESULTS: 89 patients and 176 physicians completed three rounds of the Delphi exercise. The most highly rated items of response involved disease activity [extent of organ involvement, physician global assessment], mortality [survival], and patient-reported outcomes [patient global assessment and health-related quality of life measures]. Achievement of specific BVAS scores were highly rated only by physicians. Items highly rated only by patients included laboratory measures [changes on urinalysis and acute phase reactants], pain, and fatigue. Additional items related to damage and adverse events were highly rated by both groups. CONCLUSION: There is consensus between patients and physicians on many items considered important to measure when assessing response to treatment in AAV. There are some items considered important by only patients or only physicians. These data will inform the next steps in the development criteria of response to treatment in AAV.
引用
- Quinn KA, Monti S, Christensen R, et al. An international Delphi exercise to identify items of importance for measuring response to treatment in ANCA-associated vasculitis. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2022. PMID: 35523065. doi:10.1016/j.semarthrit.2022.152021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。