使用OMERACT半定量评分系统对痛风超声病变的回顾性纵向评估
本研究对63例经显微镜证实的痛风患者在接受达标降尿酸治疗期间进行超声(28个关节、14条肌腱)纵向评估,分别于基线、6个月和12个月采集静态图像/视频,以二分类法和OMERACT半定量评分系统对痛风石、双轨征和聚集物进行评分。结果显示半定量评分下痛风石和双轨征在随访期间显著减少,聚集物几乎无变化;半定量评分的反应性明显高于二分类评分,最敏感指标为痛风石-双轨征半定量联合评分,并提出了可行的关节/肌腱监测组合。
要点
- 半定量评分下痛风石和双轨征在随访期间显著减少,聚集物几乎无变化。
- 半定量痛风石和双轨征总评分的反应性明显高于二分类评分。
- 最敏感的尿酸盐沉积指标为痛风石-双轨征半定量联合总评分。
核心结论
- OMERACT共识半定量超声痛风评分系统显示纵向有效性,在静态图像/视频评估中痛风石和双轨征对治疗高度敏感。
- 作者提出了一个敏感的尿酸盐沉积超声指标和一个可行的关节/肌腱监测组合,可能在未来纵向研究中有价值。
研究设计与样本
- 对63例经显微镜证实的痛风患者进行纵向评估,患者在开始或增加降尿酸治疗时接受超声检查(28个关节、14条肌腱),并在6个月和12个月后重复。
- 保存病变的静态图像/视频,对痛风石、双轨征(DC)和聚集物进行二分类和半定量评分,计算患者水平的病变评分及联合晶体总评分,并在患者和关节/肌腱水平计算反应性。
主要发现
- 回顾性评估的静态图像/视频显示,二分类和半定量评分下痛风石和双轨征均出现统计学显著减少,而聚集物在随访期间几乎无变化。
- 半定量痛风石和双轨征总评分的反应性明显高于二分类评分。
- 最敏感的尿酸盐沉积指标为痛风石-双轨征半定量联合总评分。
- 可行的监测关节/肌腱组合包括双侧膝关节、第一和第二跖趾关节以及腓骨肌腱和远端髌腱,这些部位代表最普遍和反应性最高的位点。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 静态图像/视频为回顾性评估。
- 原文结论指出所提出的指标和关节/肌腱组合可能在未来纵向研究中有价值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The objectives of this study were (i) to evaluate the responsiveness of gout-specific US lesions representing urate deposition in patients receiving treat-to-target urate-lowering therapy using a binary and the OMERACT-defined semi-quantitative scoring systems; (ii) to determine the most responsive US measure for urate deposition and the optimal joint/tendon set for monitoring this. METHODS: US (28 joints, 14 tendons) was performed in microscopically verified gout patients initiating/increasing urate-lowering therapy and repeated after 6 and 12 months. Static images/videos of pathologies were stored and scored binarily and semi-quantitatively for tophus, double contour sign (DC) and aggregates. Lesion scores were calculated at patient level, as were combined crystal sum scores. Responsiveness of lesions-scored binarily and semi-quantitatively-was calculated at both patient and joint/tendon levels. RESULTS: Sixty-three patients underwent longitudinal evaluation. The static images/videos assessed retrospectively showed statistically significant decreases in tophus and DC, when scored binarily and semi-quantitatively, whereas aggregates were almost unchanged during follow-up. The responsiveness of the semi-quantitative tophus and DC sum scores were markedly higher than when using binary scoring. The most responsive measure for urate deposition was a combined semi-quantitative tophus-DC-sum score. A feasible joint/tendon set for monitoring included knee and first-second MTP joints and peroneus and distal patella tendons (all bilateral), representing the most prevalent and responsive sites. CONCLUSION: The OMERACT consensus-based semi-quantitative US gout scoring system showed longitudinal validity with both tophus and DC being highly responsive to treatment when assessed in static images/videos. A responsive US measure for urate deposition and a feasible joint/tendon set for monitoring were proposed and may prove valuable in future longitudinal studies.
引用
- Christiansen SN, Østergaard M, Slot O, et al. Retrospective longitudinal assessment of ultrasound gout lesions using the OMERACT semi-quantitative scoring system. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2022. PMID: 35298610. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keac179
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。