脊柱关节炎超声附着点炎定义的可靠性评估:一项大型、多中心、国际性网络研究的结果
该网络研究由15个国家37个风湿病中心的47名风湿病学家对101张图像和39个视频片段进行评估,检验OMERACT超声附着点炎定义中各基本组分的观察者间和观察者内可靠性。结果显示骨侵蚀和附着点处能量多普勒信号的可靠性良好,附着点增厚和低回声区可靠性较低,作者对后两者的定义提出修订疑问。
要点
- 骨侵蚀和附着点处能量多普勒信号的观察者间可靠性最高,Light's kappa分别为0.77和0.72。
- 附着点增厚的观察者间可靠性为中等(Light's kappa 0.41),低回声区为一般(Light's kappa 0.37)。
- 观察者内可靠性总体高于观察者间评估,各超声基本组分呈现相似趋势。
核心结论
- 该多中心、国际性网络研究显示,OMERACT超声定义中骨侵蚀、附着点处能量多普勒信号和附着点骨赘/钙化的可靠性良好。
- 附着点增厚和低回声区的可靠性低,对这两个超声诊断附着点炎主要组分的定义是否应修订提出疑问。
研究设计与样本
- 该网络练习基于对下肢主要附着点的101张图像和39个视频片段的评估,由15个国家37个风湿病中心的47名风湿病学家完成。
- 评估内容包括OMERACT脊柱关节炎超声附着点炎定义中的基本组分:低回声区、附着点增厚、附着点处能量多普勒信号、附着点骨赘/钙化、骨侵蚀。
- 观察者间和观察者内可靠性采用Light's kappa、Cohen's kappa、患病率与偏倚调整kappa(PABAK)及其95%CI计算。
主要发现
- 骨侵蚀的观察者间Light's kappa为0.77(0.76-0.78),PABAK为0.86(0.86-0.87);附着点处能量多普勒信号的观察者间Light's kappa为0.72(0.71-0.73),PABAK为0.73(0.73-0.74)。
- 附着点骨赘/钙化的观察者间Light's kappa为0.65(0.64-0.65),PABAK为0.67(0.67-0.68)。
- 附着点增厚的观察者间Light's kappa为0.41(0.41-0.42),PABAK为0.41(0.40-0.42);低回声区的观察者间Light's kappa为0.37(0.36-0.38),PABAK为0.37(0.37-0.38)。
- 观察者内可靠性练习呈现相似趋势,但所有超声基本组分的可靠性总体高于观察者间评估。
关键数值与推荐
- 骨侵蚀观察者间Light's kappa 0.77(0.76-0.78),PABAK 0.86(0.86-0.87)。
- 附着点处能量多普勒信号观察者间Light's kappa 0.72(0.71-0.73),PABAK 0.73(0.73-0.74)。
- 附着点骨赘/钙化观察者间Light's kappa 0.65(0.64-0.65),PABAK 0.67(0.67-0.68)。
- 附着点增厚观察者间Light's kappa 0.41(0.41-0.42),PABAK 0.41(0.40-0.42)。
- 低回声区观察者间Light's kappa 0.37(0.36-0.38),PABAK 0.37(0.37-0.38)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the reliability of the OMERACT US Task Force definition of US enthesitis in SpA. METHODS: In this web exercise, based on the evaluation of 101 images and 39 clips of the main entheses of the lower limbs, the elementary components included in the OMERACT definition of US enthesitis in SpA (hypoechoic areas, entheseal thickening, power Doppler signal at the enthesis, enthesophytes/calcifications, bone erosions) were assessed by 47 rheumatologists from 37 rheumatology centres in 15 countries. Inter- and intra-observer reliability of the US components of enthesitis was calculated using Light's kappa, Cohen's kappa, Prevalence And Bias Adjusted Kappa (PABAK) and their 95% CIs. RESULTS: Bone erosions and power Doppler signal at the enthesis showed the highest overall inter-reliability [Light's kappa: 0.77 (0.76-0.78), 0.72 (0.71-0.73), respectively; PABAK: 0.86 (0.86-0.87), 0.73 (0.73-0.74), respectively], followed by enthesophytes/calcifications [Light's kappa: 0.65 (0.64-0.65), PABAK: 0.67 (0.67-0.68)]. This was moderate for entheseal thickening [Light's kappa: 0.41 (0.41-0.42), PABAK: 0.41 (0.40-0.42)], and fair for hypoechoic areas [Light's kappa: 0.37 (0.36-0.38); PABAK: 0.37 (0.37-0.38)]. A similar trend was observed in the intra-reliability exercise, although this was characterized by an overall higher degree of reliability for all US elementary components compared with the inter-observer evaluation. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this multicentre, international, web-based study show a good reliability of the OMERACT US definition of bone erosions, power Doppler signal at the enthesis and enthesophytes/calcifications. The low reliability of entheseal thickening and hypoechoic areas raises questions about the opportunity to revise the definition of these two major components for the US diagnosis of enthesitis.
引用
- Di Matteo A, Cipolletta E, Destro Castaniti GM, et al. Reliability assessment of the definition of ultrasound enthesitis in SpA: results of a large, multicentre, international, web-based study. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2022. PMID: 35293988. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keac162
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。