文献速递其他结缔组织病

系统性硬化症皮肤受累评估中的超声与弹性成像:一项聚焦验证与标准化的系统文献综述——世界硬皮病基金会皮肤超声工作组

Ultrasound and elastography in the assessment of skin involvement in systemic sclerosis: A systematic literature review focusing on validation and standardization - WSF Skin Ultrasound Group.
PubMed 文献 · Semin Arthritis Rheum · 2022-01-10

世界硬皮病基金会皮肤超声工作组按 Cochrane 手册开展系统文献综述,检索 Pubmed、Cochrane Library 与 Embase 数据库 1979年1月1日至2021年5月31日文献,最终纳入 46 项研究。B 型超声用于 30 项研究(65.2%),弹性成像用于 9 项(19.6%),两者兼用 7 项(15.2%);超声厚度评估对 mRSS 与皮肤组织学检查显示良好的信度与聚合效度证据,而回声强度与硬度评估的效度证据有限,敏感度、重测信度、临床试验区分度及意义阈值证据有限或缺失。

要点

  • B 型超声用于 30 项研究(65.2%),弹性成像 9 项(19.6%),两者兼用 7 项(15.2%)。
  • 超声厚度评估对 mRSS 与皮肤组织学检查显示良好的信度与聚合效度证据。
  • 回声强度与硬度评估对组织学检查的效度证据有限,图像采集与分析标准化亟待推进。

核心结论

  • 超声是系统性硬化症皮肤厚度测量有效且可靠的工具,但超声皮肤回声强度评估与弹性成像皮肤硬度评估在可行性、效度和区分度方面存在显著知识空白。
  • 需要标准化图像采集与分析以促进进展。

研究设计与样本

  • 在世界硬皮病基金会皮肤超声工作组内按 Cochrane 手册开展系统文献综述,采用 PICO 框架。
  • 检索 Pubmed、Cochrane Library 和 Embase 数据库 1979年1月1日至2021年5月31日的文献,纳入评估超声量化系统性硬化症患者皮肤病理的全文文献,限成人、任何语言。
  • 由两名评价者独立进行偏倚风险评估、数据提取与综合;3248 篇参考文献中纳入 46 项研究。

主要发现

  • B 型超声用于 30 项研究(65.2%),弹性成像用于 9 项(19.6%),两者兼用 7 项(15.2%)。
  • 报告的超声结局指标域为厚度(57.8%)与回声强度(17.2%),弹性成像指标域为硬度(25%)。
  • 图像采集与分析方法高度异质且常报告不足,妨碍跨研究数据综合,背景因素与可行性亦然。
  • 数据综合提示超声厚度评估对 mRSS 和皮肤组织学检查有良好信度与聚合效度证据;硬度与回声强度对组织学检查的效度证据有限。
  • 对所报告超声指标域,关于变化敏感度、重测信度、临床试验区分度或意义阈值的证据有限或缺失。

关键数值与推荐

  • 超声厚度评估对 mRSS 与皮肤组织学发现显示良好信度与聚合效度证据。
  • 超声回声强度与弹性成像皮肤硬度评估对组织学发现的效度证据有限。
  • 变化敏感度、重测信度、临床试验区分度及意义阈值的证据对所报告超声指标域有限或缺失。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 图像采集与分析方法高度异质且常报告不足,妨碍跨研究数据综合。
  • 背景因素与可行性的报告同样存在上述问题。
  • 硬度与回声强度对组织学检查的效度证据有限。
  • 变化敏感度、重测信度、临床试验区分度或意义阈值的证据对所报告超声指标域有限或缺失。
  • 需要标准化图像采集与分析以促进进展。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To summarize the published evidence in the literature on the role of ultrasound and elastography to assess skin involvement in systemic sclerosis (SSc). METHODS: A systematic literature review (SLR) was performed within the "Skin Ultrasound Working Group" of the World Scleroderma Foundation, according to the Cochrane Handbook. A search was conducted in Pubmed, Cochrane Library and Embase databases from 1/1/1979 to 31/5/2021, using the participants, intervention, comparator and outcomes (PICO) framework. Only full-text articles involving adults, reported in any language, assessing ultrasound to quantify skin pathology in SSc patients. Two reviewers performed the assessment of risk of bias, data extraction and synthesis, independently. RESULTS: Forty-six studies out of 3248 references evaluating skin ultrasound and elastography domains were included. B-mode ultrasound was used in 30 studies (65.2%), elastography in nine (19.6%), and both methods in seven (15.2%). The ultrasound outcome measure domains reported were thickness (57.8%) and echogenicity (17.2%); the elastography domain was stiffness (25%). Methods used for image acquisition and analysis were remarkably heterogeneous and frequently under-reported, precluding data synthesis across studies. The same applies to contextual factors and feasibility. Our data syntheses indicated evidence of good reliability and convergent validity for ultrasound thickness evaluation against mRSS and skin histological findings. Stiffness and echogenicity have limited evidence for validity against histological findings. Evidence for sensitivity to change, test-retest reliability, clinical trial discrimination or thresholds of meaning is limited or absent for reported ultrasound domains. CONCLUSION: Ultrasound is a valid and reliable tool for skin thickness measurement in SSc but there are significant knowledge gaps regarding skin echogenicity assessment by ultrasound and skin stiffness evaluation by elastography in terms of feasibility, validity and discrimination. Standardization of image acquisition and analysis is needed to foster progress.

来源:Semin Arthritis Rheum,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Santiago T, Santos E, Ruaro B, et al. Ultrasound and elastography in the assessment of skin involvement in systemic sclerosis: A systematic literature review focusing on validation and standardization - WSF Skin Ultrasound Group. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2022. PMID: 35039184. doi:10.1016/j.semarthrit.2022.151954

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。