皮肌炎皮疹肤色代表性中的种族差异:一项系统综述
该系统性综述评估了2011至2021年间出版的93本教材及3个在线图像数据库中皮肌炎皮疹图像的肤色代表性。在分析的561张图像中,73.1%为MMSCS 1-2(极浅肤色),仅1.8%为MMSCS 8-10(极深肤色),评分者间信度高(W=0.835)。结论认为浅肤色患者在教育材料中代表性更高,深肤色代表性不足。
要点
- 561张皮肌炎皮疹图像中73.1%为MMSCS 1-2,仅1.8%为MMSCS 8-10。
- MMSCS 5-10的图像中59.2%来自在线数据库,教材图像中80.6%来自皮肤科书籍。
- 深肤色代表性不足可能导致皮肌炎皮肤受累特征描述不充分及临床试验误排除。
核心结论
- 浅肤色患者在教育材料中的代表性高于深肤色患者,深肤色在皮肌炎皮肤教育材料中代表性不足。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述纳入2011至2021年间出版的59本皮肤科、11本神经科、10本神经肌肉、7本风湿科和6本内科教材及3个在线图像数据库(UpToDate、VisualDx和DermNet NZ)。
- 作者独立使用Massey和Martin肤色量表(MMSCS)从1(极浅)至10(极深)评分,取中位数为最终分并分组为MMSCS 1-2、3-4、5-7或8-10,采用Kendall和谐系数(W)评估评分者间信度。
主要发现
- 共提取621张图像,561张纳入分析,73.1%为MMSCS 1-2,13.4%为3-4,11.8%为5-7,1.8%为8-10。
- 评分者间信度高(W=0.835)。
- MMSCS 5-10的图像中59.2%来自在线数据库,教材图像中80.6%来自皮肤科书籍。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This systemic review assesses skin tone representation in images of DM rashes in medical education literature. METHODS: A review was performed of 59 dermatology, 11 neurology, 10 neuromuscular, 7 rheumatology and 6 internal medicine textbooks published between 2011 and 2021 and 3 online image databases (UpToDate, VisualDx and DermNet NZ) that were available through an online medical school library. After extracting images, images with poor lighting or unclear rashes were removed. Authors graded skin tone independently on the Massey and Martin Skin Colour Scale (MMSCS) from 1 (very light) to 10 (very dark). The median score was taken for a final score, grouped within MMSCS 1-2, 3-4, 5-7 or 8-10. Inter-rater reliability was assessed using Kendall's coefficient of concordance (W). RESULTS: Six hundred and twenty-one images were extracted after reviewing 93 textbooks and 3 online databases. Of the 561 images analysed, 73.1% of images represented MMSCS 1-2, followed by 3-4 (13.4%), 5-7 (11.8%) and 8-10 (1.8%). Inter-rater reliability was high (W = 0.835). Of the images in MMSCS 5-10, 59.2% were in online databases and 80.6% of textbook images were in dermatology books. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with lighter skin tones were represented in a higher number of DM-related educational materials compared with patients with darker skin tones. Our findings add to current research implicating that darker skin tones are under-represented in cutaneous educational materials, specifically for DM. This leads to the inability to properly characterize skin involvement in DM and may lead to inappropriate exclusion from clinical trials due to erroneous skin scoring.
引用
- Babool S, Bhai SF, Sanderson C, et al. Racial disparities in skin tone representation of dermatomyositis rashes: a systematic review. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2022. PMID: 34718435. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keab809
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。