文献速递流行病学与生物统计真实世界研究与卫生经济

彩色编码与警示营养标签对消费者购买行为影响的系统综述与网络Meta分析

Impact of color-coded and warning nutrition labelling schemes: A systematic review and network meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · PLoS Med · 2021-10-05

该研究系统检索1990年至2021年的随机对照试验和准实验研究,采用网络Meta分析评估彩色编码解释性标签和警示标签对消费者购买行为的影响。共纳入156项研究,发现交通灯标签、营养素警示和健康警示均可提高选择更健康产品的概率,并降低选择较不健康产品的概率;彩色编码标签在促进健康产品购买方面更优,警示标签在抑制不健康购买方面更优。

要点

  • 交通灯标签、营养素警示和健康警示均能促进消费者选择更健康的产品。
  • 营养素警示和健康警示在减少不健康产品选择上表现更佳。
  • 彩色编码标签在引导购买更健康产品方面优于警示标签。

核心结论

  • 彩色编码标签和警示标签能引导消费者购买更健康的产品,并揭示行为改变的心理机制。
  • 不同类型标签各有优势,制定正面包装营养标签政策时应考虑当地情况。
  • 研究支持强制性正面包装标签政策,以引导消费者选择并鼓励食品行业改良产品。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述与网络Meta分析,检索PubMed、Embase、Cochrane Central和SCOPUS从1990年1月1日至2021年5月24日的文献。
  • 纳入随机对照试验和准实验研究,主要结局为消费者购买和消费行为的变化。
  • 共纳入156项研究(101项RCT和55项非RCT),其中134项研究(120篇文章)符合Meta分析条件。

主要发现

  • 交通灯标签、营养素警示和健康警示与选择更健康产品的概率增加相关(OR及95%CI:TLS 1.5 [1.2, 1.87];NW 3.61 [2.82, 4.63];HW 1.65 [1.32, 2.06])。
  • Nutri-Score和警示标签与选择较不健康产品的概率降低相关(NS 0.66 [0.53, 0.82];NW 0.65 [0.54, 0.77];HW 0.64 [0.53, 0.76])。
  • NS和NW分别与购买产品整体健康性评分提高7.9%和26%相关。
  • TLS、NS和NW与购买产品总能量、钠、脂肪和饱和脂肪含量降低相关(如总能量:TLS -6.5%;NS -6%;NW -12.9%)。
  • 彩色编码标签在引导购买更健康产品方面优于警示标签(NS vs NW:1.51 [1.08, 2.11]),警示标签在抑制不健康购买方面优于交通灯标签(NW vs TLS:0.81 [0.67, 0.98];HW vs TLS:0.8 [0.63, 1])。

关键数值与推荐

  • 交通灯标签、营养素警示和健康警示与选择更健康产品的概率增加相关(OR及95%CI:TLS 1.5 [1.2, 1.87];NW 3.61 [2.82, 4.63];HW 1.65 [1.32, 2.06])。
  • Nutri-Score和警示标签与选择较不健康产品的概率降低相关(NS 0.66 [0.53, 0.82];NW 0.65 [0.54, 0.77];HW 0.64 [0.53, 0.76])。
  • NS和NW分别与购买产品整体健康性评分提高7.9%和26%相关。
  • TLS、NS和NW与购买产品总能量、钠、脂肪和饱和脂肪含量降低相关(如总能量:TLS -6.5%;NS -6%;NW -12.9%)。
  • 彩色编码标签在引导购买更健康产品方面优于警示标签(NS vs NW:1.51 [1.08, 2.11]),警示标签在抑制不健康购买方面优于交通灯标签(NW vs TLS:0.81 [0.67, 0.98];HW vs TLS:0.8 [0.63, 1])。

临床怎么用

  • 政策制定者可依据当地情况选择彩色编码标签或警示标签,以引导消费者选择更健康产品。
  • 研究支持强制性正面包装营养标签政策,以鼓励食品行业改良产品配方。
  • 标签通过改善消费者对营养信息的理解,进而影响其对不健康产品的负面感知或对健康食品的积极态度。

局限性

  • 不同标签类型比较存在高度异质性和不一致性。
  • 真实世界研究数量有限(95%为实验室研究)。
  • 缺乏长期影响评估。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Suboptimal diets are a leading risk factor for death and disability. Nutrition labelling is a potential method to encourage consumers to improve dietary behaviour. This systematic review and network meta-analysis (NMA) summarises evidence on the impact of colour-coded interpretive labels and warning labels on changing consumers' purchasing behaviour. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We conducted a literature review of peer-reviewed articles published between 1 January 1990 and 24 May 2021 in PubMed, Embase via Ovid, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, and SCOPUS. Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and quasi-experimental studies were included for the primary outcomes (measures of changes in consumers' purchasing and consuming behaviour). A frequentist NMA method was applied to pool the results. A total of 156 studies (including 101 RCTs and 55 non-RCTs) nested in 138 articles were incorporated into the systematic review, of which 134 studies in 120 articles were eligible for meta-analysis. We found that the traffic light labelling system (TLS), nutrient warning (NW), and health warning (HW) were associated with an increased probability of selecting more healthful products (odds ratios [ORs] and 95% confidence intervals [CIs]: TLS, 1.5 [1.2, 1.87]; NW, 3.61 [2.82, 4.63]; HW, 1.65 [1.32, 2.06]). Nutri-Score (NS) and warning labels appeared effective in reducing consumers' probability of selecting less healthful products (NS, 0.66 [0.53, 0.82]; NW,0.65 [0.54, 0.77]; HW,0.64 [0.53, 0.76]). NS and NW were associated with an increased overall healthfulness (healthfulness ratings of products purchased using models such as FSAm-NPS/HCSP) by 7.9% and 26%, respectively. TLS, NS, and NW were associated with a reduced energy (total energy: TLS, -6.5%; NS, -6%; NW, -12.9%; energy per 100 g/ml: TLS, -3%; NS, -3.5%; NW, -3.8%), sodium (total sodium/salt: TLS, -6.4%; sodium/salt per 100 g/ml: NS: -7.8%), fat (total fat: NS, -15.7%; fat per 100 g/ml: TLS: -2.6%; NS: -3.2%), and total saturated fat (TLS, -12.9%; NS: -17.1%; NW: -16.3%) content of purchases. The impact of TLS, NS, and NW on purchasing behaviour could be explained by improved understanding of the nutrition information, which further elicits negative perception towards unhealthful products or positive attitudes towards healthful foods. Comparisons across label types suggested that colour-coded labels performed better in nudging consumers towards the purchase of more healthful products (NS versus NW: 1.51 [1.08, 2.11]), while warning labels have the advantage in discouraging unhealthful purchasing behaviour (NW versus TLS: 0.81 [0.67, 0.98]; HW versus TLS: 0.8 [0.63, 1]). Study limitations included high heterogeneity and inconsistency in the comparisons across different label types, limited number of real-world studies (95% were laboratory studies), and lack of long-term impact assessments. CONCLUSIONS: Our systematic review provided comprehensive evidence for the impact of colour-coded labels and warnings in nudging consumers' purchasing behaviour towards more healthful products and the underlying psychological mechanism of behavioural change. Each type of label had different attributes, which should be taken into consideration when making front-of-package nutrition labelling (FOPL) policies according to local contexts. Our study supported mandatory front-of-pack labelling policies in directing consumers' choice and encouraging the food industry to reformulate their products. PROTOCOL REGISTRY: PROSPERO (CRD42020161877).

来源:PLoS Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Song J, Brown MK, Tan M, et al. Impact of color-coded and warning nutrition labelling schemes: A systematic review and network meta-analysis. PLoS Med. 2021. PMID: 34610024. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1003765

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。