管芯与Magill钳用于经鼻气管插管的随机对照试验比较
两组各30例,管芯组总插管时间显著短于Magill钳组(52.4±3.1秒 vs 59.7±5.1秒),两组轻度鼻出血分别为5例和6例,均无口腔组织或牙齿损伤。结论认为使用一次性灭菌管芯是经鼻气管插管的便捷选择。
要点
- 管芯法经鼻气管插管总时间短于Magill钳法(52.4±3.1秒 vs 59.7±5.1秒)。
- 管芯组全部完成插管且未使用Magill钳,两组轻度鼻出血分别为5例和6例。
- 两组均未观察到口腔组织或牙齿损伤。
核心结论
- 使用由一次性灭菌管芯构成的管芯法是经鼻气管插管的便捷选择。
主要发现
- 所有经鼻气管插管均成功完成,管芯组无任何患者使用Magill钳。
- 两组总经鼻气管插管时间存在显著差异:Magill钳组59.7(5.1)秒 vs 管芯组52.4(3.1)秒。
- 轻度鼻出血:Magill钳组6例,管芯组5例(6/30 vs 5/30)。
- 两组均未观察到口腔组织或牙齿损伤。
临床怎么用
- 在经鼻气管插管中可采用弯曲至鼻腔生理曲线并以无菌石蜡油润滑的管芯辅助插管,以缩短插管时间。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Magill forceps are frequently used to complete nasotracheal intubation (NTI). We aimed to identify a tube core that could conveniently facilitate the NTI process without using Magill forceps. METHODS: Sixty patients scheduled for oral and maxillofacial surgeries were enrolled in our study and divided into two groups (30 per group) with no differences with regard to demographic data. In the Magill forceps group (Group M), a wire-reinforced endotracheal catheter was inserted into the trachea using Magill forceps. However, in the tube core group (Group T), a tube core bent to the physiological curve of the nasal cavity and lubricated with aseptic paraffin oil was inserted into the endotracheal catheter and was then withdrawn after the endotracheal catheter was advanced through the glottis under direct vision. RESULTS: All NTIs were completed successfully, and Magill forceps were not used on any patient in Group T. There was a significant difference in total NTI time between the two groups (Group M, 59.7 (5.1) s vs Group T, 52.4 (3.1) s). Mild epistaxis was observed in 6 patients in Group M and 5 patients in Group T (6/30 vs 5/30, respectively). No damage to oral tissue or teeth was observed in either group. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that using a tube core, consisting of a disposable sterilised stylet, is a convenient choice for NTI. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Patient enrolment was conducted after registration in the Chinese Clinical Trial Registry ( www.Chictr.org.cn , ChiCTR190002 7387). This trial was prospectively registered on 11 November 2019.
引用
- Hu R, Niu JY, Wu LN, et al. Comparison of a tube core and Magill forceps for nasotracheal intubation: a randomised controlled trial. Trials. 2021. PMID: 34645510. doi:10.1186/s13063-021-05677-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。