临床试验招募人员对入排标准使用经验的探索性横断面在线调查
该研究通过对英国临床试验招募人员的探索性横断面在线调查,收集其解读与应用入排标准的经验及对标准沟通与制定方式的看法。823名合格受访者中,79%报告在某些试验中遇到入排标准问题,9%在多数试验中遇到。问题主题以清晰性(67%评论)、可行性(34%)和适宜性(14%)为主,部分问题导致患者错误纳入或排除。
要点
- 79%招募人员报告某些试验入排标准存在问题,9%在多数试验中遇到。
- 问题类型以清晰性(67%评论)、可行性(34%)、适宜性(14%)为主。
- 74%受访者支持在方案制定早期由招募人员审阅入排标准。
核心结论
- 调查证实试验入排标准存在不理想情况,清晰性问题最常报告,可行性与适宜性评论提示部分招募人员认为标准及评估可能妨碍招募。
研究设计与样本
- 探索性横断面在线调查,对象为英国参与本试验单位试验的招募人员,共823名合格受访者参与。
主要发现
- 79%受访者报告在某些试验中遇到入排标准问题,9%在多数试验中遇到。
- 问题类型主题为清晰性(67%评论)、可行性(34%)、适宜性(14%)。
- 27%报告存在某种程度问题者称问题导致患者被错误纳入试验,40%称导致错误排除。
- 56%受访者主要从试验方案中获取入排标准,74%支持招募人员在方案制定早期审阅入排标准。
临床怎么用
- 招募人员可在方案制定早期参与审阅入排标准,以提升清晰性、可行性与适宜性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Eligibility criteria are a fundamental element of clinical trial design, defining who can and who should not participate in a trial. Problems with the design or application of criteria are known to occur and pose risks to participants' safety and trial integrity, sometimes also negatively impacting on trial recruitment and generalisability. We conducted a short, exploratory survey to gather evidence on UK recruiters' experiences interpreting and applying eligibility criteria and their views on how criteria are communicated and developed. METHODS: Our survey included topics informed by a wider programme of work at the Clinical Trials Research Unit, University of Leeds, on assuring eligibility criteria quality. Respondents were asked to answer based on all their trial experience, not only on experiences with our trials. The survey was disseminated to recruiters collaborating on trials run at our trials unit, and via other mailing lists and social media. The quantitative responses were descriptively analysed, with inductive analysis of free-text responses to identify themes. RESULTS: A total of 823 eligible respondents participated. In total, 79% of respondents reported finding problems with eligibility criteria in some trials, and 9% in most trials. The main themes in the types of problems experienced were criteria clarity (67% of comments), feasibility (34%), and suitability (14%). In total, 27% of those reporting some level of problem said these problems had led to patients being incorrectly included in trials; 40% said they had led to incorrect exclusions. Most respondents (56%) reported accessing eligibility criteria mainly in the trial protocol. Most respondents (74%) supported the idea of recruiter review of eligibility criteria earlier in the protocol development process. CONCLUSIONS: Our survey corroborates other evidence about the existence of suboptimal trial eligibility criteria. Problems with clarity were the most often reported, but the number of comments on feasibility and suitability suggest some recruiters feel eligibility criteria and associated assessments can hinder recruitment to trials. Our proposal for more recruiter involvement in protocol development has strong support and some potential benefits, but questions remain about how best to implement this. We invite other trialists to consider our other suggestions for how to assure quality in trial eligibility criteria.
引用
- Cragg WJ, McMahon K, Oughton JB, et al. Clinical trial recruiters' experiences working with trial eligibility criteria: results of an exploratory, cross-sectional, online survey in the UK. Trials. 2021. PMID: 34689802. doi:10.1186/s13063-021-05723-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。