概率界分析:决策分析建模与成本效果分析中量化参数不确定性的新方法
针对健康干预决策中证据有限的问题,本研究提出概率界分析(PBA),用未知累积分布函数上下界构成的区间(p-box)表达参数不确定性,无需指定精确分布。给出常见数据组合下p-box公式及传播至黑箱模型的方法,并通过两个案例与概率敏感性分析(PSA)对比展示其特性与效用。
要点
- PBA用p-box区间表达参数不确定性,无需假设具体分布形式,减少建模假设。
- 给出最小值、最大值、中位数、均值或标准差常见组合下p-box的公式。
- 提供将p-box传播至黑箱数学模型及基于PBA结果决策的方法。
核心结论
- PBA为建模者在现有数据约束下以最少假设进行参数不确定性量化提供了实用工具。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,提出概率界分析(PBA)并给出p-box公式与传播方法,通过两个案例与PSA对比。
主要发现
- PBA将参数未知概率分布的不确定性表达为未知累积分布函数上下界构成的区间(p-box),不假设特定分布形式。
- 研究给出了常见情形(最小值、最大值、中位数、均值或标准差的给定组合)下p-box的公式。
- 研究描述了将p-box传播至黑箱数学模型的方法,并引入了基于PBA结果的决策方法。
- 两个案例展示了PBA与PSA相比的特性与效用。
临床怎么用
- 在证据有限、难以指定精确概率分布时,建模者可用PBA以最少假设量化参数不确定性并支持决策分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Decisions about health interventions are often made using limited evidence. Mathematical models used to inform such decisions often include uncertainty analysis to account for the effect of uncertainty in the current evidence base on decision-relevant quantities. However, current uncertainty quantification methodologies, including probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA), require modelers to specify a precise probability distribution to represent the uncertainty of a model parameter. This study introduces a novel approach for representing and propagating parameter uncertainty, probability bounds analysis (PBA), where the uncertainty about the unknown probability distribution of a model parameter is expressed in terms of an interval bounded by lower and upper bounds on the unknown cumulative distribution function (p-box) and without assuming a particular form of the distribution function. We give the formulas of the p-boxes for common situations (given combinations of data on minimum, maximum, median, mean, or standard deviation), describe an approach to propagate p-boxes into a black-box mathematical model, and introduce an approach for decision-making based on the results of PBA. We demonstrate the characteristics and utility of PBA vs PSA using two case studies. In sum, this study provides modelers with practical tools to conduct parameter uncertainty quantification given the constraints of available data and with the fewest assumptions.
引用
- Iskandar R. Probability bound analysis: A novel approach for quantifying parameter uncertainty in decision-analytic modeling and cost-effectiveness analysis. Stat Med. 2021. PMID: 34528265. doi:10.1002/sim.9195
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。