文献速递流行病学与生物统计真实世界研究与卫生经济基础与转化研究

现金+项目与单纯现金转移对低中收入国家五岁以下儿童早期结局的效果比较:系统综述与荟萃分析

Effectiveness of cash-plus programmes on early childhood outcomes compared to cash transfers alone: A systematic review and meta-analysis in low- and middle-income countries.
PubMed 文献 · PLoS Med · 2021-09-28

该研究系统检索42个数据库等来源,纳入17项在低中收入国家比较现金+项目与单纯现金转移的研究,其中11项进行荟萃分析。结果显示仅现金+食品转移改善年龄别身高及降低发育迟缓风险,现金+营养行为改变沟通、心理社会刺激或儿童保护未见额外效果。

要点

  • 现金+食品转移可改善年龄别身高并降低发育迟缓风险。
  • 现金+营养行为改变沟通对生长指标无额外效果。
  • 现金+心理社会刺激或儿童保护未见额外效果。

核心结论

  • 本研究发现少数现金+组合比单纯现金转移更有效,现金+食品转移和现金+初级卫生保健显示出最大的额外效果迹象。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统检索42个数据库、捐助机构、灰色文献来源和试验注册库,截至2021年4月6日获得5097篇 unique 文章。
  • 纳入标准为在低中收入国家比较现金+项目与单纯现金转移对五岁以下儿童结局影响的随机或准实验研究,共纳入17项研究,其中11项进行荟萃分析。
  • 使用Cochrane偏倚风险和ROBINS-I工具评估偏倚风险,对至少3项试验报告同一结局的现金+干预类别进行随机效应荟萃分析,并在PROSPERO预注册(CRD42018108017)。

主要发现

  • 现金+食品转移与单纯现金转移相比,改善年龄别身高(d=0.08 SD(0.03, 0.14),p=0.02),并显著降低发育迟缓风险(OR=0.82(0.74, 0.92),p=0.01)。
  • 现金+食品转移对改善身长别体重(d=-0.13(-0.42, 0.16),p=0.24)或年龄别体重z评分(d=-0.06(-0.28, 0.15),p=0.43)无额外影响。
  • 现金+营养行为改变沟通对生长指标无额外影响;现金+心理社会刺激对认知发展无额外影响;现金+儿童保护对父母使用暴力管教或完全积极养育无额外影响。
  • 叙述性综合证据提示,与单纯现金转移相比,现金+初级卫生保健可能在降低死亡率方面有更大影响,现金+食品转移可能在危机情境下预防急性营养不良方面有更大影响。

临床怎么用

  • 在设计和选择现金+干预时,应优先考虑现金+食品转移以改善儿童生长和降低发育迟缓风险。
  • 现金+初级卫生保健可能有助于降低死亡率,尤其在危机情境下可考虑现金+食品转移以预防急性营养不良。
  • 不应假定所有现金+组合均优于单纯现金转移,需根据具体附加组件评估其额外效果。

局限性

  • 比较现金+干预与单纯现金转移的研究数量较少。
  • 研究间可能存在高度异质性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: To strengthen the impact of cash transfers, these interventions have begun to be packaged as cash-plus programmes, combining cash with additional transfers, interventions, or services. The intervention's complementary ("plus") components aim to improve cash transfer effectiveness by targeting mediating outcomes or the availability of supplies or services. This study examined whether cash-plus interventions for infants and children <5 are more effective than cash alone in improving health and well-being. METHODS AND FINDINGS: Forty-two databases, donor agencies, grey literature sources, and trial registries were systematically searched, yielding 5,097 unique articles (as of 06 April 2021). Randomised and quasi-experimental studies were eligible for inclusion if the intervention package aimed to improve outcomes for children <5 in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) and combined a cash transfer with an intervention targeted to Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 2 (No Hunger), SDG3 (Good Health and Well-being), SDG4 (Education), or SDG16 (Violence Prevention), had at least one group receiving cash-only, examined outcomes related to child-focused SDGs, and was published in English. Risk of bias was appraised using Cochrane Risk of Bias and ROBINS-I Tools. Random effects meta-analyses were conducted for a cash-plus intervention category when there were at least 3 trials with the same outcome. The review was preregistered with PROSPERO (CRD42018108017). Seventeen studies were included in the review and 11 meta-analysed. Most interventions operated during the first 1,000 days of the child's life and were conducted in communities facing high rates of poverty and often, food insecurity. Evidence was found for 10 LMICs, where most researchers used randomised, longitudinal study designs (n = 14). Five intervention categories were identified, combining cash with nutrition behaviour change communication (BCC, n = 7), food transfers (n = 3), primary healthcare (n = 2), psychosocial stimulation (n = 7), and child protection (n = 4) interventions. Comparing cash-plus to cash alone, meta-analysis results suggest Cash + Food Transfers are more effective in improving height-for-age (d = 0.08 SD (0.03, 0.14), p = 0.02) with significantly reduced odds of stunting (OR = 0.82 (0.74, 0.92), p = 0.01), but had no added impact in improving weight-for-height (d = -0.13 (-0.42, 0.16), p = 0.24) or weight-for-age z-scores (d = -0.06 (-0.28, 0.15), p = 0.43). There was no added impact above cash alone from Cash + Nutrition BCC on anthropometrics; Cash + Psychosocial Stimulation on cognitive development; or Cash + Child Protection on parental use of violent discipline or exclusive positive parenting. Narrative synthesis evidence suggests that compared to cash alone, Cash + Primary Healthcare may have greater impacts in reducing mortality and Cash + Food Transfers in preventing acute malnutrition in crisis contexts. The main limitations of this review are the few numbers of studies that compared cash-plus interventions against cash alone and the potentially high heterogeneity between study findings. CONCLUSIONS: In this study, we observed that few cash-plus combinations were more effective than cash transfers alone. Cash combined with food transfers and primary healthcare show the greatest signs of added effectiveness. More research is needed on when and how cash-plus combinations are more effective than cash alone, and work in this field must ensure that these interventions improve outcomes among the most vulnerable children.

来源:PLoS Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Little MT, Roelen K, Lange BCL, et al. Effectiveness of cash-plus programmes on early childhood outcomes compared to cash transfers alone: A systematic review and meta-analysis in low- and middle-income countries. PLoS Med. 2021. PMID: 34582447. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1003698

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。