COVID-19 大流行期间开展动态系统评价的方法学挑战:概念性论文
本文基于两项 Cochrane 动态系统评价(LSR)的经验及其他非 Cochrane LSR 中识别的问题,讨论 COVID-19 大流行期间开展 LSR 面临的方法学挑战。作者围绕研究设计、干预与对照、结局指标变化及检索策略提出方法学考量,并讨论何时更新或不更新评价及报告变更的透明性。结论认为 LSR 适合大流行情境,更新决策取决于疾病演变、证据涌现、具体评价问题及团队资源。
要点
- 动态系统评价适合 COVID-19 等证据快速演变的大流行情境。
- 需关注研究设计、干预与对照、结局指标及检索策略的方法学挑战。
- 更新与否应综合疾病演变、证据、评价问题及团队资源,并透明报告变更。
核心结论
- 动态系统评价非常适合大流行情境,即使面临新的方法与临床挑战。
- 是否更新动态系统评价取决于疾病演变、证据涌现、具体评价问题及团队资源。
研究设计与样本
- 概念性论文,基于两项 Cochrane 动态系统评价的经验及多项非 Cochrane 动态系统评价中识别的问题。
主要发现
- COVID-19 大流行带来流行病学格局变化、临床不确定性和证据演变,迫使调整标准动态系统评价方法。
- 方法学考量重点涉及研究设计、干预与对照、结局指标变化及检索策略。
临床怎么用
- 开展动态系统评价时应考虑研究设计、干预与对照、结局指标及检索策略的动态调整。
- 决定是否更新评价时需综合疾病演变、证据、具体评价问题及团队资源,并透明报告变更。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A living systematic review (LSR) is an emerging review type that makes use of continual updating. In the COVID-19 pandemic, we were confronted with a shifting epidemiological landscape, clinical uncertainties and evolving evidence. These unexpected challenges compelled us to amend standard LSR methodology. OBJECTIVE AND OUTLINE: Our primary objective is to discuss some challenges faced when conducting LSRs in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, and to provide methodological guidance for others doing similar work. Based on our experience and lessons learned from two Cochrane LSRs and challenges identified in several non-Cochrane LSRs, we highlight methodological considerations, particularly with regards to the study design, interventions and comparators, changes in outcome measure, and the search strategy. We discuss when to update, or rather when not to update the review, and the importance of transparency when reporting changes. LESSONS LEARNED AND CONCLUSION: We learned that a LSR is a very suitable review type for the pandemic context, even in the face of new methodological and clinical challenges. Our experience showed that the decision for updating a LSR depends not only on the evolving disease or emerging evidence, but also on the individual review question and the review teams' resources.
引用
- Iannizzi C, Dorando E, Burns J, et al. Methodological challenges for living systematic reviews conducted during the COVID-19 pandemic: A concept paper. J Clin Epidemiol. 2021. PMID: 34525406. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2021.09.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。