指南可操作声明的分类与框架:避免非正式推荐
该研究通过迭代方法分析世界卫生组织与美国血液学会指南案例,提出区分五类可操作声明的分类框架,并测试其识别非正式推荐的能力。框架要求声明符合预设标准、结构清晰且表述可识别,旨在帮助指南制定者避免非正式推荐并提升用户理解与实施。
要点
- 指南可操作声明分为五类,包括正式推荐与非正式推荐等。
- 非正式推荐与正式推荐在证据考量与制定过程上存在差异。
- 按框架明确标注声明类型可避免非正式推荐并改善实施。
核心结论
- 识别、标准化并明确标注可操作声明有助于指南制定者避免非正式推荐并提升用户理解与实施。
研究设计与样本
- 采用迭代方法,基于世界卫生组织与美国血液学会指南案例开发初始框架,并随机选取不同机构新冠指南推荐进行测试与优化。
- 咨询方法学专家与指南制定者完善最终框架。
主要发现
- 框架区分五类可操作声明:正式推荐、研究推荐、良好实践声明、实施考虑与工具提示、非正式推荐。
- 非正式推荐与正式推荐在证据考量与制定过程上存在差异。
- 可操作声明应回应预设标准,并在指南中具有清晰结构与可识别表述。
临床怎么用
- 指南制定者可依据该框架识别并明确标注各类可操作声明,避免非正式推荐。
- 通过标准化声明类型提升用户对指南的理解与实施。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To propose a taxonomy and framework that identifies and presents actionable statements in guidelines. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We took an iterative approach reviewing case studies of guidelines produced by the World Health Organization and the American Society of Hematology to develop an initial conceptual framework. We then tested it using randomly selected recommendations from published guidelines addressing COVID-19 from different organizations, evaluated its results, and refined it before retesting. The urgency and availability of evidence for development of these recommendations varied. We consulted with experts in research methodology and guideline developers to improve the final framework. RESULTS: The resulting taxonomy and framework distinguishes five types of actional statements: formal recommendations; research recommendations; good practice statements; implementation considerations, tools and tips; and informal recommendations. These statements should respond to a priori established criteria and require a clear structure and recognizable presentation in a guideline. Most importantly, this framework identifies informal recommendations that differ from formal recommendations by how they consider evidence and in their development process. CONCLUSION: The identification, standardization and explicit labelling of actionable statements according to the framework may support guideline developers to create actionable statements with clear intent, avoid informal recommendations and improve their understanding and implementation by users.
引用
- Lotfi T, Hajizadeh A, Moja L, et al. A taxonomy and framework for identifying and developing actionable statements in guidelines suggests avoiding informal recommendations. J Clin Epidemiol. 2021. PMID: 34562579. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2021.09.028
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。