行为减重项目特征与项目结束后体重变化的关系:系统综述与荟萃分析
该研究系统检索并荟萃分析了249项随机试验(n=59 081),评估行为减重项目特征对项目结束后体重变化速率的影响。结果显示项目结束后干预组体重反弹快于对照组,但组间差异至少维持五年;初始减重越多反弹越快,经济激励与更快反弹相关,项目外可及性与更慢反弹相关。
要点
- 初始减重越多,项目结束后体重反弹越快,但减重获益仍可维持至少五年。
- 经济激励与项目结束后更快体重反弹相关(约1–1.5 kg/年)。
- 项目外持续可及性与更慢的体重反弹相关。
核心结论
- 项目结束后干预组体重反弹快于无干预对照组,但组间差异至少维持五年。
- 初始减重越多与更快反弹相关,但减重获益仍可维持至少五年。
- 项目外持续可及性预测更慢反弹,经济激励预测更快反弹,其他特征无明确关联。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与荟萃分析,检索试验注册库、11个电子数据库及引文追溯(最新检索2019年12月)。
- 纳入成人超重或肥胖的行为减重项目随机试验,报告≥12个月且含项目结束及结束后的结局。
- 共分析249项试验(n=59 081),平均随访两年(最长30年)。
- 采用Cochrane偏倚风险评估工具(版本1),56%研究偏倚风险不明确、21%低、23%高。
主要发现
- 项目结束后干预组体重反弹快于无干预对照组,速率为0.12–0.32 kg/年。
- 项目结束时每减重1 kg与更快反弹相关,速率为0.13–0.19 kg/年。
- 经济激励与更快反弹相关,速率为1–1.5 kg/年。
- 部分代餐干预与更快反弹相关,但校正项目期间减重后关联不再显著。
- 项目外可及性与更慢反弹相关;互动强度逐渐降低的项目在多变量分析中与更慢反弹相关但效应量小。
临床怎么用
- 行为减重项目结束后应预期体重反弹,尤其初始减重较多者。
- 项目结束后保持持续可及性或有助于减缓体重反弹。
- 经济激励策略需关注项目结束后更快反弹的风险。
局限性
- 数据在项目结束后五年以上有限。
- 56%研究偏倚风险不明确,23%为高风险。
- 其他项目特征未能解释体重反弹的异质性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine if the characteristics of behavioural weight loss programmes influence the rate of change in weight after the end of the programme. DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis. DATA SOURCES: Trial registries, 11 electronic databases, and forward citation searching (from database inception; latest search December 2019). Randomised trials of behavioural weight loss programmes in adults with overweight or obesity, reporting outcomes at ≥12 months, including at the end of the programme and after the end of the programme. REVIEW METHODS: Studies were screened by two independent reviewers with discrepancies resolved by discussion. 5% of the studies identified in the searches met the inclusion criteria. One reviewer extracted the data and a second reviewer checked the data. Risk of bias was assessed with Cochrane's risk of bias tool (version 1). The rate of change in weight was calculated (kg/month; converted to kg/year for interpretability) after the end of the programme in the intervention versus control groups by a mixed model with a random intercept. Associations between the rate of change in weight and prespecified variables were tested. RESULTS: Data were analysed from 249 trials (n=59 081) with a mean length of follow-up of two years (longest 30 years). 56% of studies (n=140) had an unclear risk of bias, 21% (n=52) a low risk, and 23% (n=57) a high risk of bias. Regain in weight was faster in the intervention versus the no intervention control groups (0.12-0.32 kg/year) but the difference between groups was maintained for at least five years. Each kilogram of weight lost at the end of the programme was associated with faster regain in weight at a rate of 0.13-0.19 kg/year. Financial incentives for weight loss were associated with faster regain in weight at a rate of 1-1.5 kg/year. Compared with programmes with no meal replacements, interventions involving partial meal replacements were associated with faster regain in weight but not after adjustment for weight loss during the programme. Access to the programme outside of the study was associated with slower regain in weight. Programmes where the intensity of the interaction reduced gradually were also associated with slower regain in weight in the multivariable analysis, although the point estimate suggested that the association was small. Other characteristics did not explain the heterogeneity in regain in weight. CONCLUSION: Faster regain in weight after weight loss was associated with greater initial weight loss, but greater initial weight loss was still associated with reduced weight for at least five years after the end of the programme, after which data were limited. Continued availability of the programme to participants outside of the study predicted a slower regain in weight, and provision of financial incentives predicted faster regain in weight; no other clear associations were found. STUDY REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42018105744.
引用
- Hartmann-Boyce J, Theodoulou A, Oke JL, et al. Association between characteristics of behavioural weight loss programmes and weight change after programme end: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ. 2021. PMID: 34404631. doi:10.1136/bmj.n1840
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。