黎巴嫩巴勒斯坦难民医院治疗支付政策变化的影响:一项卫生经济学分析
2016年UNRWA将黎巴嫩签约公立和私立医院二级诊疗的全额付费改为医院承担10%费用,而PRCS医院仍全额覆盖。
要点
- 政策后患者更倾向选择PRCS医院,选择可能性增加16%。
- PRCS住院时间延长,患者多住1天的概率为20%。
- 公立和私立医院住院时间分别平均缩短22%和28%,总体减少13%。
核心结论
- UNRWA对二级诊疗引入费用分担后,患者更常选择PRCS医院且住院时间更长。
- 公立和私立医院覆盖削减10%并未为UNRWA节省费用,因为患者通过改变医院偏好适应了费用增加。
研究设计与样本
- 卫生经济学分析,比较2016年1月至5月与2016年6月至2017年10月政策前后医院使用差异。
- 采用回归分析估计政策对不同医院类型需求、住院时间和UNRWA及患者总治疗费用的影响。
主要发现
- 约64%患者就诊于PRCS,26%私立,9%公立医院。
- 经济计量估计显示,2016年6月后患者选择PRCS医院而非其他类型医院的可能性高16%。
- PRCS医院平均住院时间增加,患者在PRCS医院比公立或私立医院多住1天的概率为20%。
- 公立医院住院时间平均缩短22%,私立医院平均缩短28%,总体住院时间减少13%。
- 按账单价值(即UNRWA和患者的总费用),政策变化前后无差异。
临床怎么用
- 提示在贫困与冲突背景下,费用分担政策可能改变患者就医选择而非节省支付方费用。
- 为UNRWA未来政策设计提供卫生系统措施反馈。
局限性
- 无对照组,无法论证政策与结果间的因果关系。
- 稳健性检验(包括评估2017年)支持结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In 2016, the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) changed from covering the full cost of secondary care in contracted public and private hospitals in Lebanon, Jordan, to requesting that these hospitals pay 10% of the costs. Meanwhile, services at UNWRA-contracted Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS) hospitals remained fully covered. We did a health economics analysis to assess the effects this policy change on the demand for secondary care in UNRWA hospitals. METHODS: We assessed the difference in use of different types of hospital (demand) from January to May, 2016, and June, 2016, to October, 2017, before and after the payment policy change. Data were collected by UNWRA from each hospital's database, including individual-level inpatient information for 22 193 Palestinian refugees in Lebanon who were admitted to secondary care at UNRWA-contracted hospitals (public, private, and PRCS). We used regression analyses to estimate the effects on demand for the different hospital types, length of stay, and total costs of treatment to UNWRA and patients. FINDINGS: Around 64% of patients attended PRCS, 26% private, and 9% public hospitals. According to our econometric estimations, after June, 2016, patients were 16% more likely to choose a PRCS hospital over the other types of hospital. Mean length of stay in PRCS hospitals increased, leading to a 20% chance of patients staying 1 day longer in PRCS hospitals than in public or private hospitals. However, the length of stay in public and private hospitals decreased (by an average of 22% at public and 28% at private hospitals), giving an overall decrease in length of stay of 13%. In terms of bill value (ie, total costs to UNRWA and to patients), we found no difference between before and after the policy change. INTERPRETATION: The introduction of the UNWRA cost-sharing component for secondary care led patients to attend PRCS hospitals more often and for longer periods of time. The finding that no effect was seen on costs for UNRWA or patients suggests that the 10% cut in cover at public and private hospitals did not save any money for UNWRA because patients managed to accommodate the increase by changing their hospital preference The study is limited in that it cannot argue causality between the policy and the results found because there is no control group. Nevertheless, robustness testing, including assessing the year 2017, supports our results. This study contributes to the literature on the impacts of co-payments in health care in a very specific context of poverty and conflict that has rarely been subject to scrutiny and provides feedback to UNRWA on a health-care system measure, relevant for future policy designs. FUNDING: None.
引用
- de Almeida SV, Paolucci G, Seita A, et al. Effects of change in hospital treatment payment policy for Palestinian refugees in Lebanon: a health economics analysis. Lancet. 2021. PMID: 34227955. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(21)01509-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。