文献速递临床试验与 GCP医学教育与科研方法

将定性研究嵌入随机对照试验以改善招募:两项骨科手术试验招募优化研究的发现

Embedding qualitative research in randomised controlled trials to improve recruitment: findings from two recruitment optimisation studies of orthopaedic surgical trials.
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2021-07-17

该研究通过对英国全国性骨科手术随机对照试验(ACTIVE)和混合方法随机可行性研究(PRESTO)进行两项定性过程评估,采用半结构化访谈和主题分析,探讨招募中的关键问题。结论是需要方法学转变,将现有证据转化为优化招募的方法。

要点

  • 招募是随机对照试验的主要挑战,骨科手术试验因 eligible 患者少和偏好问题更具挑战。
  • 关键因素包括均势、随机化、沟通、患者处境、利他主义和信任。
  • 需考虑资格标准操作化和复杂患者路径,以及非招募人员对患者偏好的影响。

核心结论

  • 需要方法学转变,确保现有证据被所有招募相关人员使用,并转化为优化未来试验招募的方法。

研究设计与样本

  • 两项定性过程评估,嵌套于英国全国性骨科手术随机对照试验(ACTIVE)和混合方法随机可行性研究(PRESTO)。
  • 通过电话进行半结构化访谈,数据采用主题分析。

主要发现

  • 发现映射到混合方法系统评价的招募因素,强调均势、随机化、沟通、患者处境、利他主义和信任的重要性。
  • 强调考虑资格标准如何操作化以及复杂患者路径对招募的影响。
  • 非招募健康专业人员通过建议患者将接受某种治疗而影响其治疗偏好,这一影响不应被低估。

临床怎么用

  • 在招募过程中应重视均势、随机化、沟通、患者处境、利他主义和信任等因素。
  • 需考虑资格标准的操作化和复杂患者路径对招募的影响。
  • 注意非招募健康专业人员对患者治疗偏好的潜在影响。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Recruitment of patients is one of the main challenges when designing and conducting randomised controlled trials (RCTs). Trials of rare injuries or those that include surgical interventions pose added challenges due to the small number of potentially eligible patients and issues with patient preferences and surgeon equipoise. We explore key issues to consider when recruiting to orthopaedic surgical trials from the perspective of staff and patients with the aim of informing the development of strategies to improve recruitment in future research. DESIGN: Two qualitative process evaluations of a UK-wide orthopaedic surgical RCT (ACTIVE) and mixed methods randomised feasibility study (PRESTO). Qualitative semi-structured interviews were conducted and data was analysed thematically. SETTING: NHS secondary care organisations throughout the UK. Interviews were undertaken via telephone. PARTICIPANTS: Thirty-seven health professionals including UK-based spinal and orthopaedic surgeons and individuals involved in recruitment to the ACTIVE and PRESTO studies (e.g. research nurses, surgeons, physiotherapists). Twenty-two patients including patients who agreed to participate in the ACTIVE and PRESTO studies (n=15) and patients that declined participation in the ACTIVE study (n=7) were interviewed. RESULTS: We used a mixed methods systematic review of recruiting patients to randomised controlled trials as a framework for reporting and analysing our findings. Our findings mapped onto those identified in the systematic review and highlighted the importance of equipoise, randomisation, communication, patient's circumstances, altruism and trust in clinical and research teams. Our findings also emphasised the importance of considering how eligibility criteria are operationalised and the impact of complex patient pathways when recruiting to surgical trials. In particular, the influence of health professionals, who are not involved in trial recruitment, on patients' treatment preferences by suggesting they would receive a certain treatment ahead of recruitment consultations should not be underestimated. CONCLUSIONS: A wealth of evidence exploring factors affecting recruitment to randomised controlled trials exists. A methodological shift is now required to ensure that this evidence is used by all those involved in recruitment and to ensure that existing knowledge is translated into methods for optimising recruitment to future trials. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ACTIVE: ( ISRCTN98152560 ). Registered on 06/03/2018. PRESTO: ( ISRCTN12094890 ). Registered on 22/02/2018.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Scantlebury A, McDaid C, Brealey S, et al. Embedding qualitative research in randomised controlled trials to improve recruitment: findings from two recruitment optimisation studies of orthopaedic surgical trials. Trials. 2021. PMID: 34274006. doi:10.1186/s13063-021-05420-4

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。