常见择期骨科手术的临床有效性:1级证据伞状综述
该伞状综述评估了10种常见择期骨科手术对比不治疗、安慰剂或非手术治疗的临床有效性,并检查对临床指南的影响。随机对照试验证据支持腕管减压术和全膝关节置换优于非手术治疗,但无随机对照试验专门比较全髋置换或半月板修复与非手术治疗,其余六种手术的试验证据未显示优于非手术治疗。
要点
- 腕管减压术和全膝关节置换有随机对照试验证据支持优于非手术治疗。
- 全髋置换和半月板修复无随机对照试验专门比较与非手术治疗。
- 其余六种常见择期骨科手术的试验证据未显示优于非手术治疗。
核心结论
- 随机对照试验证据支持腕管减压术和全膝关节置换优于非手术治疗。
- 无随机对照试验专门比较全髋置换或半月板修复与非手术治疗。
- 其他六种手术的试验证据未显示优于非手术治疗。
- 尽管缺乏强证据,某些手术仍被国家指南推荐用于特定情况。
研究设计与样本
- 伞状综述,纳入随机对照试验的荟萃分析,若无则纳入其他研究设计。
- 研究10种常见择期骨科手术:关节镜下前交叉韧带重建、关节镜下膝关节半月板修复、关节镜下膝关节部分半月板切除术、关节镜下肩袖修复、关节镜下肩峰下减压、腕管减压、腰椎减压、腰椎融合、全髋置换、全膝关节置换。
- 检索Medline、Embase、Cochrane Library和参考文献,截至2020年9月。
- 两名独立研究者提取数据,第三名参与达成共识。
- 使用AMSTAR工具评估方法学质量,Jadad决策算法确定最佳证据,NICE证据搜索检查指南推荐是否反映证据体。
主要发现
- 随机对照试验证据支持腕管减压术和全膝关节置换优于非手术治疗。
- 无随机对照试验专门比较全髋置换或半月板修复与非手术治疗。
- 其他六种手术的试验证据未显示优于非手术治疗。
临床怎么用
- 临床决策应认识到许多常见择期骨科手术缺乏高质量证据支持优于非手术治疗。
- 腕管减压术和全膝关节置换可依据随机对照试验证据考虑优于非手术治疗。
- 对于缺乏强证据的手术,需结合国家指南推荐和具体情况谨慎选择。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine the clinical effectiveness of common elective orthopaedic procedures compared with no treatment, placebo, or non-operative care and assess the impact on clinical guidelines. DESIGN: Umbrella review of meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials or other study designs in the absence of meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials. DATA SOURCES: Ten of the most common elective orthopaedic procedures-arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, arthroscopic meniscal repair of the knee, arthroscopic partial meniscectomy of the knee, arthroscopic rotator cuff repair, arthroscopic subacromial decompression, carpal tunnel decompression, lumbar spine decompression, lumbar spine fusion, total hip replacement, and total knee replacement-were studied. Medline, Embase, Cochrane Library, and bibliographies were searched until September 2020. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES: Meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials (or in the absence of meta-analysis other study designs) that compared the clinical effectiveness of any of the 10 orthopaedic procedures with no treatment, placebo, or non-operative care. DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Summary data were extracted by two independent investigators, and a consensus was reached with the involvement of a third. The methodological quality of each meta-analysis was assessed using the Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews instrument. The Jadad decision algorithm was used to ascertain which meta-analysis represented the best evidence. The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence Evidence search was used to check whether recommendations for each procedure reflected the body of evidence. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Quality and quantity of evidence behind common elective orthopaedic interventions and comparisons with the strength of recommendations in relevant national clinical guidelines. RESULTS: Randomised controlled trial evidence supports the superiority of carpal tunnel decompression and total knee replacement over non-operative care. No randomised controlled trials specifically compared total hip replacement or meniscal repair with non-operative care. Trial evidence for the other six procedures showed no benefit over non-operative care. CONCLUSIONS: Although they may be effective overall or in certain subgroups, no strong, high quality evidence base shows that many commonly performed elective orthopaedic procedures are more effective than non-operative alternatives. Despite the lack of strong evidence, some of these procedures are still recommended by national guidelines in certain situations. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42018115917.
引用
- Blom AW, Donovan RL, Beswick AD, et al. Common elective orthopaedic procedures and their clinical effectiveness: umbrella review of level 1 evidence. BMJ. 2021. PMID: 34233885. doi:10.1136/bmj.n1511
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。