将因果推断的工具变量方法与估计目标框架相连接
本文是一篇教程,回顾因果推断基本工具(包括图模型与潜在结局)及工具变量分析可纳入的若干概念框架,详细讨论如何将这些方法与ICH E9附录中的治疗政策、主分层和假设性估计目标策略相映射,并给出使用标准回归模型的实施细节,最后将所述方法应用于与两项近期药物试验高度匹配的模拟数据。
要点
- 工具变量方法可用于处理随机化后或中间事件影响的治疗效应估计。
- 需将IV分析与E9附录中的治疗政策、主分层和假设性估计目标策略对应。
- 每种估计策略依赖特定假设,需评估其可检验性并开展敏感性分析。
核心结论
- 本教程系统连接了工具变量方法与E9附录的估计目标框架,并展示了在标准回归模型中的实施与假设检验思路。
研究设计与样本
- 教程文章,回顾因果推断基本工具与概念框架,并通过匹配两项近期药物试验的模拟数据进行应用演示。
主要发现
- 讨论了将IV分析映射到治疗政策、主分层和假设性估计目标策略的方法及其实施细节。
- 强调了每种估计策略一致性的假设条件、可经验检验的程度以及可放松特定假设的敏感性分析。
临床怎么用
- 在药物开发中可依据E9附录的估计目标策略选择相应的IV分析方法,并明确所需假设与敏感性分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Causal inference methods are gaining increasing prominence in pharmaceutical drug development in light of the recently published addendum on estimands and sensitivity analysis in clinical trials to the E9 guideline of the International Council for Harmonisation. The E9 addendum emphasises the need to account for post-randomization or 'intercurrent' events that can potentially influence the interpretation of a treatment effect estimate at a trial's conclusion. Instrumental Variables (IV) methods have been used extensively in economics, epidemiology, and academic clinical studies for 'causal inference,' but less so in the pharmaceutical industry setting until now. In this tutorial article we review the basic tools for causal inference, including graphical diagrams and potential outcomes, as well as several conceptual frameworks that an IV analysis can sit within. We discuss in detail how to map these approaches to the Treatment Policy, Principal Stratum and Hypothetical 'estimand strategies' introduced in the E9 addendum, and provide details of their implementation using standard regression models. Specific attention is given to discussing the assumptions each estimation strategy relies on in order to be consistent, the extent to which they can be empirically tested and sensitivity analyses in which specific assumptions can be relaxed. We finish by applying the methods described to simulated data closely matching two recent pharmaceutical trials to further motivate and clarify the ideas.
引用
- Bowden J, Bornkamp B, Glimm E, et al. Connecting Instrumental Variable methods for causal inference to the Estimand Framework. Stat Med. 2021. PMID: 34288021. doi:10.1002/sim.9143
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。