医学非Cochrane系统综述撤稿现状与原因的系统综述
该研究系统检索MEDLINE、Embase、Retraction Watch Database和Google Scholar,分析2004至2020年间被撤稿的159篇医学非Cochrane系统综述。结果显示超过70%的撤稿综述由中国作者主导且隶属于医院,虚假同行评议和不可靠数据是最常见撤稿原因,发表至撤稿中位时间为14个月。
要点
- 虚假同行评议和非可靠数据是医学非Cochrane系统综述撤稿的主要原因。
- 2004至2020年撤稿的159篇综述中超过70%由中国作者主导并隶属于医院。
- 发表至撤稿中位时间14个月,科研不端导致的撤稿耗时更长。
核心结论
- 全球被撤稿的系统综述总数在增加,尤其在中国。
- 最常见的撤稿原因是虚假同行评议和数据不可靠,多数综述在发表一年多后才被撤稿。
- 需要更好的伦理监管体系与同行评议文化,并遵循COPE撤稿指南,作者应加强系统综述方法学技能。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索MEDLINE、Embase、Retraction Watch Database和Google Scholar,查找所有被撤稿的非Cochrane系统综述。
- 共纳入2004至2020年间被撤稿的159篇医学非Cochrane系统综述。
主要发现
- 超过70%的撤稿综述由中国作者主导且隶属于医院。
- 最大比例的撤稿通知由出版商与编辑联合发布。
- 虚假同行评议是最常见撤稿原因,其次为研究选择或数据分析错误导致的数据不可靠。
- 发表至撤稿的中位时间为14个月。
- 因科研不端撤稿的综述比因诚实错误撤稿的综述耗时更长。
临床怎么用
- 提示科研人员和期刊关注系统综述的同行评议质量与数据可靠性。
- 建议遵循COPE撤稿指南并加强系统综述方法学培训。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To analyze the retraction status and reasons of non-Cochrane systematic reviews (SRs) in medicine. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: MEDLINE, Embase, Retraction Watch Database and Google Scholar were systematically searched to find all retracted non-Cochrane SRs. RESULTS: Of 159 non-Cochrane SRs in medicine retracted between 2004 and 2020, more than 70% were led by authors from China and affiliated with hospitals. The largest proportion of retraction notices were issued by the publisher and editor(s) jointly. Fraudulent peer-review was the most common reason for retraction, followed by unreliable data meaning errors in study selection or data analysis. The median time between publication and retraction was 14 months, and SRs retracted due to research misconduct took longer to retract than honest error. CONCLUSION: The total number of retracted SRs is increasing worldwide, in particular in China. The most common reasons for retraction are fraudulent peer-review and unreliable data, and in most cases the SR is retracted more than a year after publication. Better systems of ethical oversight and culture to improve the process of peer review and adherence to the COPE retraction guidance are needed, and authors should strengthen their skills in SR methodology.
引用
- Shi Q, Wang Z, Zhou Q, et al. More consideration is needed for retracted non-Cochrane systematic reviews in medicine: a systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2021. PMID: 34186193. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2021.06.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。