性别对研究人员评估的影响:一项随机对照试验
该随机对照试验旨在检验在简历相同的情况下,评审人是否偏好女性或男性,以及职业阶段对评审人选择的影响。研究邀请巴西牙科领域的1级和2级研究员作为外部评审人,随机分配收到女性或男性的简历,并从科学贡献、领导潜力、团队工作能力和国际经验四个方面进行评分。结果显示,在所有简历类别中,男性简历获得的评分均高于女性简历,且男性在领导潜力方面被看好的可能性比同等女性简历高出近四分之三。结论指出,牙科领域的学术界存在强烈的性别偏见,亟需采取隐性偏见培训等措施。
要点
- 在简历相同的情况下,男性申请者在科学贡献、领导潜力、团队合作和国际经验方面均获得更高评分。
- 男性简历被评价为具有领导潜力的可能性比同等女性简历高出近四分之三。
- 性别偏见在牙科领域学术界普遍存在,不受申请者职业阶段影响。
核心结论
- 性别偏见在牙科领域的学术界非常普遍,且不受研究人员职业阶段的影响。
- 亟需实施隐性偏见培训等措施,以避免或至少减少更多女性受到伤害。
研究设计与样本
- 采用模拟博士后评审过程的随机对照试验设计。
- 邀请巴西牙科领域的1级和2级研究员作为外部评审人,随机分配收到女性或男性的简历。
- 评审人需从科学贡献、领导潜力、团队工作能力和国际经验四个方面对简历进行0到10分的评分。
主要发现
- 在所有评估的简历类别中,男性简历获得的评分均高于女性简历。
- 稳健方差泊松回归显示,无论申请者职业阶段如何,男性在所有类别中更可能获得更高评分。
- 男性简历被评价为具有领导潜力的可能性比同等女性简历高出近四分之三。
关键数值与推荐
- 评审人使用0到10分对科学贡献、领导潜力、团队工作能力和国际经验进行评分。
- 男性简历在领导潜力方面被看好的可能性比同等女性简历高出近四分之三。
临床怎么用
- 在科研人员招聘和晋升评审中应警惕性别偏见,采取盲审或结构化评估。
- 机构应推行隐性偏见培训,减少评估中的性别差异。
局限性
- 研究仅针对巴西牙科领域的研究人员,结论外推需谨慎。
- 模拟评审过程可能与真实评审环境存在差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This randomized controlled trial aimed to test whether women or men would be preferred with identical curriculum vitae (CV); and the impact of the career stage in the evaluators' choice. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A simulated post-doctoral process was carried forward to be assessed for judgment. Level 1 and 2 Brazilian fellow researchers in the field of Dentistry were invited to act as external reviewers in a post-doctoral process and were randomly assigned to receive a CV from a woman or a man. They were required to rate the CV from 0 to 10 in scientific contribution, leadership potential, ability to work in groups, and international experience. RESULTS: For all categories of CVs evaluated, CVs from men received higher scores compared to the CVs from women. Robust variance Poisson regressions demonstrated that men were more likely to receive higher scores in all categories, despite applicants' career stage. For example, CVs from men were nearly three quarters more likely to be seen as having leadership potential than equivalent CVs from women. CONCLUSION: Gender bias is powerfully prevalent in academia in the dentistry field, despite researchers' career stage. Actions like implicit bias training must be urgently implemented to avoid (or at least decrease) that more women are harmed.
引用
- Franco MC, Helal L, Cenci MS, et al. The impact of gender on researchers' assessment: A randomized controlled trial. J Clin Epidemiol. 2021. PMID: 34118367. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2021.05.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。