贝叶斯荟萃分析中异质性先验信息量的参考分析框架
该研究针对贝叶斯正态-正态层次模型(NNHM)中异质性先验的“模糊”程度缺乏量化方法的问题,提出后验参考分析(post-RA)框架。该框架基于两个后验基准(非信息参考先验和高度反保守的适当先验),利用Hellinger距离比较边际后验以量化先验信息量。在两个医学案例中,反保守先验产生短95%可信区间(CrI)和乐观推断,保守先验产生长95%CrI和谨慎推断。
要点
- post-RA框架可量化异质性先验对实际数据的信息量。
- 反保守先验导致偏短95%CrI和乐观推断。
- 保守先验导致偏长95%CrI和谨慎推断。
核心结论
- 后验参考分析框架能确定异质性先验相对于最小信息参考先验对实际数据的信息量。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,提出基于后验基准的参考分析框架,并应用于两个医学案例。
主要发现
- 反保守异质性先验产生与参考后验相比的平峰后验,并产生更短的95%可信区间和乐观推断。
- 保守异质性先验产生尖峰后验、更长的95%可信区间和谨慎推断。
关键数值与推荐
- 使用Hellinger距离比较边际后验与两个后验基准以量化异质性先验的信息量。
- 后验基准之一由非信息参考先验诱导,另一由高度反保守的适当先验诱导。
临床怎么用
- 该框架可支持众多研究领域的贝叶斯荟萃分析,帮助评估异质性先验的信息量。
- 分析通过免费R包ra4bayesmeta实现。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Meta-analysis provides important insights for evidence-based medicine by synthesizing evidence from multiple studies which address the same research question. Within the Bayesian framework, meta-analysis is frequently expressed by a Bayesian normal-normal hierarchical model (NNHM). Recently, several publications have discussed the choice of the prior distribution for the between-study heterogeneity in the Bayesian NNHM and used several "vague" priors. However, no approach exists to quantify the informativeness of such priors, and thus, we develop a principled reference analysis framework for the Bayesian NNHM acting at the posterior level. The posterior reference analysis (post-RA) is based on two posterior benchmarks: one induced by the improper reference prior, which is minimally informative for the data, and the other induced by a highly anticonservative proper prior. This approach applies the Hellinger distance to quantify the informativeness of a heterogeneity prior of interest by comparing the corresponding marginal posteriors with both posterior benchmarks. The post-RA is implemented in the freely accessible R package ra4bayesmeta and is applied to two medical case studies. Our findings show that anticonservative heterogeneity priors produce platykurtic posteriors compared with the reference posterior, and they produce shorter 95% credible intervals (CrI) and optimistic inference compared with the reference prior. Conservative heterogeneity priors produce leptokurtic posteriors, longer 95% CrI and cautious inference. The novel post-RA framework could support numerous Bayesian meta-analyses in many research fields, as it determines how informative a heterogeneity prior is for the actual data as compared with the minimally informative reference prior.
引用
- Ott M, Plummer M, Roos M, et al. How vague is vague? How informative is informative? Reference analysis for Bayesian meta-analysis. Stat Med. 2021. PMID: 34041768. doi:10.1002/sim.9076
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。