使用GRADE方法的指南常未提供完整的经济信息:一项系统性调查
该系统性调查纳入142部指南,评估GRADE证据到决策框架中成本与经济性信息的报告情况。虽91%报告经济信息,但预设Likert判断完成率70%、未识别信息标注57%、推荐理由注释仅38%,仅2部对经济结局进行GRADE确定性评价。
要点
- GRADE指南EtD框架经济信息报告率虽高但完整性差异大。
- 仅2部指南对经济结局进行GRADE确定性评价。
- 需完善文献回顾、研究选择标准及经济模型局限的报告。
核心结论
- GRADE指南EtD框架经济信息报告总体率高但完成度差异显著,仅少数对经济结局进行确定性评价。
研究设计与样本
- 系统性调查,通过指南组织网站方便抽样纳入142部指南,审查已发表的EtD框架并统计报告方式频率。
主要发现
- 经济信息总体报告率为91%,预设EtD Likert型判断完成率为70%,标注未识别信息 across EtD框架领域为57%,提供推荐理由注释为38%。
- 仅2部指南对经济结局进行了GRADE确定性评价。
- 出现6个主题解释经济信息报告变异性,涉及干预、人群、支付方、提供方、医疗资源使用和经济模型构建因素。
关键数值与推荐
- 经济信息总体报告率91%;预设EtD Likert型判断完成率70%;标注未识别信息 across EtD框架领域57%;提供推荐理由注释38%;仅2部指南进行GRADE确定性评价。
临床怎么用
- 建议指南制定者完成预设EtD Likert型判断,明确报告文献回顾方法、研究选择标准和经济模型构建局限性,并将这些与推荐理由注释关联以提高透明度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Little is known about how developers and panel members report cost and cost effectiveness considerations in GRADE guideline Evidence-to-Decision (EtD) frameworks. A systematic survey was conducted to explore approaches and factors contributing to variability in economic information reporting. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Guideline organization websites were systematically searched to create a convenience sample of guidelines. Reviewers screened published EtD frameworks and generated frequencies of reporting approaches. We used thematic analysis to summarize factors related to variability of economic information reporting. RESULTS: We included 142 guidelines. The overall rate of reporting economic information was high (91%); however, there was variability across completion of predefined EtD Likert-type judgments (70%), noting information as not identified across EtD framework domains (57%), and providing remarks to justify recommendations (38%). Six themes contributing to variability emerged, related to: intervention, population, payor, provider, healthcare resource use, and economic model building factors. Only 2 guidelines performed a GRADE certainty appraisal of economic outcomes. CONCLUSION: Completing predefined EtD Likert-type judgments, specifically reporting a literature review approach, study selection criteria and economic model building limitations, as well as linking these to recommendation justification remarks are potential areas for improved use, adoption and adaptation of recommendation, and transparency of GRADE EtD frameworks.
引用
- Riva JJ, Bhatt M, Brunarski DJ, et al. Guidelines that use the GRADE approach often fail to provide complete economic information for recommendations: A systematic survey. J Clin Epidemiol. 2021. PMID: 33984495. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2021.04.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。