将部分依从纳入主分层分析框架
在实用性临床试验中,参与者常部分依从治疗,但多数研究将依从性二分类,可能引入偏倚。本研究扩展主分层框架,允许部分依从者拥有自己的主层和治疗水平,并设计蒙特卡洛后验抽样方法估计参数。模拟和真实试验数据表明,该方法在多数情况下优于标准主分层的有偏估计。
要点
- 标准主分层框架未包含部分依从者的层,二分类依从性可致偏倚。
- 扩展框架允许部分依从者拥有独立主层和治疗水平,适用于实用性试验。
- 模拟显示新方法在多数情况下优于标准主分层的有偏估计。
核心结论
- 扩展主分层框架可纳入部分依从者,模拟显示其推断在多数情况下优于标准主分层的有偏估计。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,设计蒙特卡洛后验抽样方法,在多种部分依从设定下模拟并应用于一项真实随机临床试验。
主要发现
- 模拟比较表明,新方法在多数情况下优于标准主分层的有偏估计。
- 模拟结果提示,在参与者仅部分依从 assigned treatment 的设定下,新方法可能提高推断准确性。
临床怎么用
- 在实用性临床试验存在部分依从时,可考虑采用扩展主分层框架替代依从性二分类分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Participants in pragmatic clinical trials often partially adhere to treatment. However, to simplify the analysis, most studies dichotomize adherence (supposing that subjects received either full or no treatment), which can introduce biases in the results. For example, the popular approach of principal stratification is based on the concept that the population can be separated into strata based on how they will react to treatment assignment, but this framework does not include strata in which a partially adhering participant would belong. We expanded the principal stratification framework to allow partial adherers to have their own principal stratum and treatment level. The expanded approach is feasible in pragmatic settings. We have designed a Monte Carlo posterior sampling method to obtain the relevant parameter estimates. Simulations were completed under a range of settings where participants partially adhered to treatment, including a hypothetical setting from a published simulation trial on the topic of partial adherence. The inference method is additionally applied to data from a real randomized clinical trial that features partial adherence. Comparison of the simulation results indicated that our method is superior in most cases to the biased estimators obtained through standard principal stratification. Simulation results further suggest that our proposed method may lead to increased accuracy of inference in settings where study participants only partially adhere to assigned treatment.
引用
- Sanders E, Gustafson P, Karim ME, et al. Incorporating partial adherence into the principal stratification analysis framework. Stat Med. 2021. PMID: 33880769. doi:10.1002/sim.8986
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。