连续时间生存结局的成本高效临床研究设计
针对时间至事件结局的临床试验设计通常不考量研究成本,本文提出一个通用框架,通过优化样本量、入组时长、随访时间和分组分配概率等组合,在保持目标把握度和I类错误水平的前提下最小化预期总研究成本。方法适用于Cox比例风险模型和Aalen可加风险模型,并在Weibull生存分布、均匀入组和指数删失假设下进行示例说明,同时提供Shiny网页应用实现。
要点
- 时间至事件结局的把握度取决于事件总数,而非仅样本量。
- 在固定效应量和I类错误下,存在多种设计组合达到相同把握度。
- 成本高效设计即最小化预期总研究成本的设计。
核心结论
- 在达到目标把握度和固定I类错误水平的前提下,最小化预期总研究成本的设计为最优成本高效设计。
- 该方法通用,可用于Cox比例风险模型或Aalen可加风险模型。
- 方法适用于多种招募和删失假设,并已通过Weibull生存结局示例说明。
研究设计与样本
- 提出一个设计成本高效研究的通用框架,用于比较连续时间至事件结局的治疗效果。
- 在固定效应量(如风险比)和I类错误水平下,于多种达到目标把握度的设计组合中最小化预期总研究成本。
- 示例采用Weibull时间至事件结局、均匀入组和指数分布删失时间,并描述了可加风险模型的情形。
- 提供了所提方法的Shiny网页应用实现。
主要发现
- 对于给定效应量,检测两组差异的把握度通常是研究中观察到的事件总数的函数。
- 相同的把握度可通过参与者总数、入组时长、总随访时间和分组分配概率的不同组合实现。
- 最优成本高效设计是使预期总研究成本最小的设计。
临床怎么用
- 设计时间至事件结局的临床试验时,应同时考虑成本因素,而不仅依赖传统把握度计算。
- 可利用所提框架或Shiny应用,在给定效应量和I类错误下探索不同设计组合的预期总成本。
局限性
- 原文未报告具体研究样本量、成本参数或实际数据验证结果。
- 示例基于Weibull生存分布、均匀入组和指数删失等假设,其他情形需进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Time-to-event outcomes are common in clinical studies. For example, the time to a first major adverse cardiovascular event (MACE, defined as CVD death, nonfatal myocardial infarction, or stroke) is a commonly used outcome in cardiovascular outcome trials. Owing to the lengthy time frame and other factors, the high costs of conducting such studies has been identified as one of the major obstacles in conducting clinical trials in the United States. However, typical approaches for designing clinical trials with time-to-event outcomes do not consider study costs. For a given effect size (eg, hazard ratio), the power to detect differences between two groups is typically a function of the total number of events observed in the study. Therefore, the same level of power will be achieved based on various combinations of the total number of participants, length of enrollment and total follow-up times, and group allocation probability. Herein, we provide a general framework for designing cost-efficient studies comparing treatments with respect to continuous time-to-event outcomes. Among the various designs that achieve the desired level of power to detect a given effect size for a fixed type-I error level, the optimal cost-efficient design is the design that minimizes the expected total study cost. The method is general and can be used for Cox proportional hazards models or Aalen additive models, and under various recruitment and censoring assumptions. The proposed approach for designing cost-efficient studies is illustrated for a Weibull time-to-event outcome with uniform recruitment and exponentially distributed censoring time. The case of an additive hazards model is also described. A Shiny web application implementation of the proposed methods is presented.
引用
- Sandoval GJ, Bebu I, Lachin JM, et al. Cost-efficient clinical studies with continuous time survival outcomes. Stat Med. 2021. PMID: 33851432. doi:10.1002/sim.8992
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。