多种相关标志物的荟萃分析方法:应用于微生物组多个α多样性指数的研究
针对每项研究报道多个相关标志物(如微生物组α多样性指数)而现有单变量或多变量荟萃分析受限的问题,提出mMeta和aMeta两种方法。mMeta通过置换非参数估计标志物间相关性,对标志物特异性合并估计的加权平均进行效应估计和假设检验;aMeta基于标志物特异性荟萃分析中最小P值的检验统计量进行假设检验。模拟评估并应用于HIV感染状态与α多样性差异的微生物组研究。
要点
- mMeta可同时合并多个相关标志物的效应估计与检验,无需预先已知标志物间相关性。
- aMeta基于最小P值检验,功效接近标志物特异性荟萃分析中的最高功效,但仅限假设检验。
- 两种方法适用于微生物组多个α多样性指数的跨研究合并,R包mMeta已公开。
核心结论
- mMeta和aMeta可在无标志物间相关性先验结果时合并多个相关标志物的多项研究。
研究设计与样本
- 提出两种荟萃分析方法mMeta和aMeta,通过计算机模拟评估并应用于真实微生物组研究。
主要发现
- mMeta基于标志物特异性合并估计的加权平均进行效应估计和假设检验,标志物间相关性通过置换非参数估计,但功效仅中等。
- aMeta基于标志物特异性荟萃分析中最小P值的检验统计量,功效接近标志物特异性荟萃分析中的最高功效,但仅限假设检验。
临床怎么用
- 在微生物组研究中合并多个α多样性指数的跨研究结果时,可选用mMeta进行效应估计或aMeta进行假设检验。
局限性
- mMeta的检验功效仅中等;aMeta仅限假设检验,不能进行效应估计。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Meta-analysis is a practical and powerful analytic tool that enables a unified statistical inference across the results from multiple studies. Notably, researchers often report the results on multiple related markers in each study (eg, various α-diversity indices in microbiome studies). However, univariate meta-analyses are limited to combining the results on a single common marker at a time, whereas existing multivariate meta-analyses are limited to the situations where marker-by-marker correlations are given in each study. Thus, here we introduce two meta-analysis methods, multi-marker meta-analysis (mMeta) and adaptive multi-marker meta-analysis (aMeta), to combine multiple studies throughout multiple related markers with no priori results on marker-by-marker correlations. mMeta is a statistical estimator for a pooled estimate and its SE across all the studies and markers, whereas aMeta is a statistical test based on the test statistic of the minimum P-value among marker-specific meta-analyses. mMeta conducts both effect estimation and hypothesis testing based on a weighted average of marker-specific pooled estimates while estimating marker-by-marker correlations non-parametrically via permutations, yet its power is only moderate. In contrast, aMeta closely approaches the highest power among marker-specific meta-analyses, yet it is limited to hypothesis testing. While their applications can be broader, we illustrate the use of mMeta and aMeta to combine microbiome studies throughout multiple α-diversity indices. We evaluate mMeta and aMeta in silico and apply them to real microbiome studies on the disparity in α-diversity by the status of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection. The R package for mMeta and aMeta is freely available at https://github.com/hk1785/mMeta.
引用
- Koh H, Tuddenham S, Sears CL, et al. Meta-analysis methods for multiple related markers: Applications to microbiome studies with the results on multiple α-diversity indices. Stat Med. 2021. PMID: 33768631. doi:10.1002/sim.8940
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。