邮件正文请求附加信息回复率高且审阅者耗时少于数据表单:一项随机研究
该研究在系统综述中嵌套随机试验,比较以邮件正文或附件数据请求表向57名研究作者索取额外信息的效果。邮件组回复率93%、附件组75%(OR 4.5,95%CI 0.9-24.0),数据完整率分别为55%与36%(OR 2.2,95%CI 0.8-6.4)。邮件组审阅者人均耗时20.2±14.4分钟,短于附件组的31.8±14.4分钟,均差11.6分钟(95%CI 4.1-19.1)。
要点
- 个性化邮件正文请求作者附加信息回复率93%,高于附件数据请求表的75%。
- 两种方式数据完整率均仅中等:邮件组55%,附件组36%。
- 邮件正文方式审阅者人均耗时较附件方式少11.6分钟。
核心结论
- 个性化邮件请求无论采用正文还是附件形式均能获得较高回复率,但数据完整率仅为中等水平。
- 以邮件正文形式提出请求比制作附件数据请求表消耗的审阅者时间更少。
研究设计与样本
- 在关于全膝关节置换术医院手术量与结局关系的系统综述中嵌套开展随机研究。
- 共57名研究作者,29名随机分入邮件正文组,28名分入附件数据请求表组。
主要发现
- 邮件组回复率93%,附件组75%,比值比4.5(95%CI 0.9-24.0)。
- 邮件组数据完整率55%,附件组36%,比值比2.2(95%CI 0.8-6.4)。
- 邮件组审阅者人均耗时20.2±14.4分钟,附件组31.8±14.4分钟,均差11.6分钟(95%CI 4.1-19.1)。
临床怎么用
- 向研究作者索取系统综述附加信息时,可优先采用个性化邮件正文而非附件数据请求表,以节省审阅者时间。
- 无论采用何种请求方式,均应预期数据完整率仅为中等水平,需预留后续跟进或替代数据获取方案。
局限性
- 研究样本量较小(57名作者),回复率与数据完整率的组间比值比置信区间均较宽且跨越无效值。
- 研究嵌套于全膝关节置换术医院手术量与结局关系的系统综述,结果向其他主题综述的外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare two strategies for requesting additional information for systematic reviews (SR) from study authors. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Randomised study within a SR of hospital volume-outcome relationships in total knee arthroplasty. We sent personalized email requests for additional information to study authors as either email text ("Email" group) or attachment with self-developed, personalised data request forms ("Attachment" group). The primary outcome was the response rate, the secondary outcomes were the data completeness rate and the reviewer time invested in author contact. RESULTS: Of 57 study authors, 29 were randomised to the Email group and 28 to the Attachment group. The response rate was 93% for Email and 75% for Attachment (odds ratio 4.5, 95% confidence interval [0.9-24.0]). Complete data were provided by 55% (Email) vs. 36% (Attachment) of authors (odds ratio 2.2 [0.8-6.4]). The mean reviewer time was shorter in the Email (mean ± standard deviation of 20.2±14.4 minutes/author) than the Attachment group (31.8±14.4 minutes/author) with a mean difference of 11.6 [4.1-19.1] minutes/author. CONCLUSION: Personalised email requests elicited high response but only moderate data completeness rates regardless of the method (email text or attachment). Email requests as text took less reviewer time than creating attachments.
引用
- Goossen K, Rombey T, Kugler CM, et al. Author queries via email text elicited high response and took less reviewer time than data forms - a randomised study within a review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2021. PMID: 33577989. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2021.02.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。