群组序贯设计中Fleming-Harrington加权log-rank检验的信息分数
本文针对非比例风险下采用Fleming-Harrington(FH)加权log-rank检验的群组序贯临床试验,讨论中期分析时信息分数(IF)的量化问题。作者将权重函数本身对IF的影响与删失的影响分离,证明不考虑删失时可利用设计阶段信息解析导出FH检验的IF,删失带来的额外影响相对较小,并据此给出设计阶段可实际使用的IF合理范围。
要点
- FH加权log-rank检验的IF可明显偏离事件数之比,设计时不应直接套用标准log-rank的做法。
- 不考虑删失时FH检验的IF可在设计阶段解析导出,删失的额外影响相对较小。
- 设计阶段无法精确预测加权log-rank的IF,但效应分解可提供可行的IF范围。
核心结论
- FH加权log-rank检验的信息分数可显著偏离中期与最终事件数之比,需正确量化。
- 将权重函数效应与删失效应分离后,可在设计阶段解析导出不考虑删失时的IF。
- 设计阶段虽无法精确预测加权检验的IF,但效应分解可给出合理且可行的IF范围。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学文章,针对群组序贯临床试验设计中FH加权log-rank检验的信息分数问题。
- 通过解析推导分离权重函数与删失对IF的影响,并用示例与模拟评估操作特性。
主要发现
- 不考虑删失时,FH检验的IF可利用设计阶段已有信息解析导出。
- 删失对IF的额外影响相对较小。
- 加权log-rank检验的IF可明显偏离标准log-rank以事件数之比定义的IF,而这一点常被忽视。
临床怎么用
- 在采用FH检验的群组序贯试验设计中期分析时,应按加权检验而非事件数之比评估信息分数。
- 可借助权重函数与删失效应的分解,在设计阶段选取合理的IF范围开展样本量与期中分析规划。
局限性
- 设计阶段无法精确预测加权log-rank检验的IF,只能给出可行范围。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
When comparing survival times of treatment and control groups under a more realistic nonproportional hazards scenario, the standard log-rank (SLR) test may be replaced by a more efficient weighted log-rank (WLR) test, such as the Fleming-Harrington (FH) test. Designing a group-sequential clinical trial with one or more interim looks during which a FH test will be performed, necessitates correctly quantifying the information fraction (IF). For SLR test, IF is defined simply as the ratio of interim to final numbers of events; but for FH test, it can deviate substantially from this ratio. In this article, we separate the effect of weight function (of FH test) alone on IF from the effect of censoring. We have shown that, without considering the effect of censoring, IF can be derived analytically for FH test using information available at the design stage and the additional effect due to censoring is relatively smaller. This article intends to serve two major purposes: first, to emphasize and rationalize the deviation of IF in weighted log-rank test from that of SLR test which is often overlooked (Jiménez, Stalbovskaya, and Jones); second, although it is impossible to predict IF for a weighted log-rank test at the design stage, our decomposition of effects on IF provides a reasonable and practically feasible range of IF to work with. We illustrate our approach with an example and provide simulation results to evaluate operating characteristics.
引用
- Kundu MG, Sarkar J. On information fraction for Fleming-Harrington type weighted log-rank tests in a group-sequential clinical trial design. Stat Med. 2021. PMID: 33624861. doi:10.1002/sim.8905
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。