高强度力量训练对膝骨关节炎患者膝痛与膝关节压缩力的影响:START随机临床试验
该评估者盲法随机临床试验纳入377例≥50岁、BMI 20-45、有膝痛和影像学膝骨关节炎的社区成人,比较高强度力量训练、低强度力量训练和注意力控制的效果。18个月随访时,高强度训练组与对照组或低强度组相比,WOMAC膝痛评分和膝关节压缩力均无统计学显著差异。
要点
- 高强度力量训练未比低强度训练或注意力控制更显著减轻膝痛。
- 高强度训练未显著降低步行时膝关节压缩力。
- 结果不支持在膝骨关节炎成人中优先选用高强度力量训练。
核心结论
- 在膝骨关节炎患者中,与低强度力量训练或注意力控制相比,高强度力量训练在18个月时未显著减轻膝痛或降低膝关节压缩力。
研究设计与样本
- 评估者盲法随机临床试验,在美国北卡罗来纳州一所大学研究中心开展。
- 纳入377例≥50岁、BMI 20-45、有膝痛和影像学膝骨关节炎的社区居住成人。
- 参与者随机分为高强度力量训练组(n=127)、低强度力量训练组(n=126)或注意力控制组(n=124)。
- 18个月随访时主要结局为WOMAC膝痛评分(0最佳-20最差,MCID=2)和步行时膝关节压缩力。
- 320例(85%)完成试验;平均年龄65岁,女性151例(40%)。
主要发现
- 18个月时调整后WOMAC膝痛评分:高强度组5.1 vs 对照组4.9,调整差值0.2(95%CI -0.6至1.1;P=.61)。
- 高强度组 vs 低强度组WOMAC膝痛评分5.1 vs 4.4,调整差值0.7(95%CI -0.1至1.6;P=.08)。
- 膝关节压缩力:高强度组2453 N vs 对照组2512 N,调整差值-58(95%CI -282至165 N;P=.61)。
- 高强度组 vs 低强度组膝关节压缩力2453 N vs 2475 N,调整差值-21(95%CI -235至193 N;P=.85)。
- 非严重不良事件87例(高强度组53、低强度组30、对照组4);严重不良事件13例与研究无关(高强度组5、低强度组3、对照组5)。
临床怎么用
- 对于有膝痛和影像学膝骨关节炎的成人,不应以减轻膝痛或降低膝关节压缩力为目的优先选择高强度力量训练而非低强度训练或注意力控制。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Thigh muscle weakness is associated with knee discomfort and osteoarthritis disease progression. Little is known about the efficacy of high-intensity strength training in patients with knee osteoarthritis or whether it may worsen knee symptoms. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether high-intensity strength training reduces knee pain and knee joint compressive forces more than low-intensity strength training and more than attention control in patients with knee osteoarthritis. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Assessor-blinded randomized clinical trial conducted at a university research center in North Carolina that included 377 community-dwelling adults (≥50 years) with body mass index (BMI) ranging from 20 to 45 and with knee pain and radiographic knee osteoarthritis. Enrollment occurred between July 2012 and February 2016, and follow-up was completed September 2017. INTERVENTIONS: Participants were randomized to high-intensity strength training (n = 127), low-intensity strength training (n = 126), or attention control (n = 124). MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Primary outcomes at the 18-month follow-up were Western Ontario McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC) knee pain (0 best-20 worst; minimally clinically important difference [MCID, 2]) and knee joint compressive force, defined as the maximal tibiofemoral contact force exerted along the long axis of the tibia during walking (MCID, unknown). RESULTS: Among 377 randomized participants (mean age, 65 years; 151 women [40%]), 320 (85%) completed the trial. Mean adjusted (sex, baseline BMI, baseline outcome values) WOMAC pain scores at the 18-month follow-up were not statistically significantly different between the high-intensity group and the control group (5.1 vs 4.9; adjusted difference, 0.2; 95% CI, -0.6 to 1.1; P = .61) or between the high-intensity and low-intensity groups (5.1 vs 4.4; adjusted difference, 0.7; 95% CI, -0.1 to 1.6; P = .08). Mean knee joint compressive forces were not statistically significantly different between the high-intensity group and the control group (2453 N vs 2512 N; adjusted difference, -58; 95% CI, -282 to 165 N; P = .61), or between the high-intensity and low-intensity groups (2453 N vs 2475 N; adjusted difference, -21; 95% CI, -235 to 193 N; P = .85). There were 87 nonserious adverse events (high-intensity, 53; low-intensity, 30; control, 4) and 13 serious adverse events unrelated to the study (high-intensity, 5; low-intensity, 3; control, 5). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Among patients with knee osteoarthritis, high-intensity strength training compared with low-intensity strength training or an attention control did not significantly reduce knee pain or knee joint compressive forces at 18 months. The findings do not support the use of high-intensity strength training over low-intensity strength training or an attention control in adults with knee osteoarthritis. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01489462.
引用
- Messier SP, Mihalko SL, Beavers DP, et al. Effect of High-Intensity Strength Training on Knee Pain and Knee Joint Compressive Forces Among Adults With Knee Osteoarthritis: The START Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA. 2021. PMID: 33591346. doi:10.1001/jama.2021.0411
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。