在临床试验中应用获益-风险评估:BRAINS项目方案
BRAINS项目旨在就如何选择适当的试验设计(如优效性)以及何时考虑纳入获益-风险方法达成专家共识。项目包含四个工作包:网络调查、快速文献综述、为期两天的共识研讨会和制定指南文件。最终将为临床研究者、资助机构和评审人员提供指南。
要点
- BRAINS项目通过共识方法制定临床试验设计和获益-风险方法应用指南。
- 项目包含调查、文献综述、共识研讨会和指南制定四个工作包。
- 指南主要面向公共资助的临床试验,但旨在适用于更广泛的研究环境。
核心结论
- 项目旨在提供指南,指导临床研究者、资助机构和评审人员选择最合适的试验设计及考虑使用获益-风险方法的时机。
研究设计与样本
- 项目包含四个工作包:网络调查、快速文献综述、为期两天的共识研讨会和制定指南文件。
临床怎么用
- 临床研究者和资助评审人员可参考该指南选择试验设计并决定是否采用获益-风险方法。
局限性
- 指南主要关注公共资助的试验,但计划适用于更广泛的研究环境。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Depending on the treatment to be investigated, a clinical trial could be designed to assess objectives of superiority, equivalence or non-inferiority. The design of the study is affected by many different elements including the control treatment, the primary outcome and associated relationships. In some studies, there could be more than one outcome of interest. In these situations, benefit-risk methodologies could be used to assess the outcomes simultaneously and consider the trade-off between the benefits against the risks of a treatment. Benefit-risk is used within the regulatory industry but seldom included within publicly funded clinical trials within the UK. This project aims to gain an expert consensus on how to select the appropriate trial design (e.g. superiority) and when to consider including benefit-risk methods. METHODS: The project will consist of four work packages: 1. A web-based survey to elicit current experiences and opinions, 2. A rapid literature review to assess any current recommendations, 3. A two-day consensus workshop to gain agreement on the recommendations, and 4. Production of a guidance document. DISCUSSION: The aim of the project is to provide a guideline for clinical researchers, grant funding bodies and reviewers for grant bodies for how to select the most appropriate trial design and when it is appropriate to consider using benefit-risk methods. The focus of the guideline will be on publicly funded trials however, the vision is that the work will be applicable across research settings and we will connect with other organisations and committees as appropriate.
引用
- Totton N, Julious S, Hughes D, et al. Utilising benefit-risk assessments within clinical trials-a protocol for the BRAINS project. Trials. 2021. PMID: 33468202. doi:10.1186/s13063-021-05022-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。