知情同意理解的现实:患者理解状况的系统综述
该系统综述检索 PubMed 与 Web of Science 数据库,纳入 14 篇关于患者对知情同意具体组成部分理解情况的文献。多数研究中,能正确回答其所同意内容的受试者很少;对自愿参与、盲法(不含对研究者设盲的了解)和随时退出三项的理解率最高(超过 50%),对安慰剂概念、随机化、安全性问题、风险和副作用的正确理解者仅占少数。作者认为,受试者对知情同意基本要素的理解偏低,这会削弱当代临床试验实践的伦理支柱。
要点
- 受试者对自愿参与、盲法、随时退出的理解率最高(超过 50%)。
- 对安慰剂概念、随机化、安全性、风险与副作用的理解者仅占少数。
- 多数研究中能正确回答所同意内容的试验受试者很少,知情同意理解水平偏低。
核心结论
- 受试者对知情同意基本组成部分的理解偏低,这一缺陷削弱了当代临床试验实践的伦理支柱,并对患者真正充分参与共享医疗决策的可行性提出疑问。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述:对 PubMed 和 Web of Science 数据库进行系统性检索,筛选关于知情同意、特别是患者对知情同意具体组成部分理解情况的文献。
- 共检索到 14 篇相关文章。
主要发现
- 多数研究中,能正确回答其所同意内容相关条目的临床试验受试者很少。
- 受试者对自愿参与、盲法(不含对研究者设盲的了解)和随时退出三项的理解水平最高,超过 50%。
- 仅少数患者表现出对安慰剂概念、随机化、安全性问题、风险和副作用的理解。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Informed consent is a basic concept of contemporary, autonomy-based medical practice and facilitates a shared decision-making model for relations between physicians and patients. Thus, the extent to which patients can comprehend the consent they grant is essential to the ethical viability of medicine as it is pursued today. However, research on patients' comprehension of an informed consent's basic components shows that their level of understanding is limited. METHODS: Systemic searches of the PubMed and Web of Science databases were performed to identify the literature on informed consent, specifically patients' comprehension of specific informed consent components. RESULTS: In total, 14 relevant articles were retrieved. In most studies, few clinical trial participants correctly responded to items that examined their awareness of what they consented to. Participants demonstrated the highest level of understanding (over 50%) regarding voluntary participation, blinding (excluding knowledge about investigators' blinding), and freedom to withdraw at any time. Only a small minority of patients demonstrated comprehension of placebo concepts, randomisation, safety issues, risks, and side effects. CONCLUSIONS: We found that participants' comprehension of fundamental informed consent components was low, which is worrisome because this lack of understanding undermines an ethical pillar of contemporary clinical trial practice and questions the viability of patients' full and genuine involvement in a shared medical decision-making process.
引用
- Pietrzykowski T, Smilowska K. The reality of informed consent: empirical studies on patient comprehension-systematic review. Trials. 2021. PMID: 33446265. doi:10.1186/s13063-020-04969-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。