医院小丑对儿科症状管理的有效性:随机与非随机对照试验的系统综述
该系统综述纳入24项随机和非随机对照试验(n=1612),评估医院小丑对住院儿童和青少年症状管理的作用。多数随机对照试验存在一些担忧或高偏倚风险,非随机对照试验多为中等偏倚风险。结果显示,医院小丑在场可显著减少医疗操作中的焦虑并改善心理适应(P<0.05),对慢性病患儿的压力、疲劳、疼痛和痛苦也有显著改善(P<0.05)。
要点
- 医院小丑可显著降低住院儿童医疗操作期间的焦虑(P<0.05)。
- 对慢性病患儿,医院小丑可显著减轻压力、疲劳、疼痛和痛苦(P<0.05)。
- 多数纳入研究存在一定偏倚风险,证据质量需谨慎解读。
核心结论
- 医院小丑在场可能有助于管理住院儿童和青少年的部分症状群,并改善心理福祉。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述纳入24项随机和非随机对照试验,共1612名住院儿童和青少年。
- 检索Medline、ISI、Cochrane CENTRAL、Science Direct、Scopus、PsycINFO、CINAHL和LILACS数据库。
- 两名研究者独立筛选、提取数据并使用Jadad量表、RoB 2和ROBINS-I工具评估偏倚风险。
主要发现
- 焦虑是最常分析的症状(n=13),其次是疼痛(n=9)、心理情绪反应和感知福祉(n=4)、压力(n=4)、癌症相关疲劳(n=3)和哭泣(n=2)。
- 5项研究使用生物标志物(主要为皮质醇)评估医院小丑后的压力或疲劳结局。
- 11项随机对照试验(85%)被评为存在一些担忧,2项为高偏倚风险;6项非随机对照试验(55%)为中等偏倚风险。
- 医院小丑在场时,儿童和青少年在各种医疗操作中报告的焦虑显著减少,心理适应改善(P<0.05)。
- 3项评估慢性病的研究显示,医院小丑干预显著减轻压力、疲劳、疼痛和痛苦(P<0.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准:住院儿童和青少年(急性或慢性病),比较医院小丑与标准护理,以症状管理为主要结局。
- 随机对照试验中85%(11/13)存在一些担忧,2项高偏倚风险;非随机对照试验中55%(6/11)为中等偏倚风险。
- 焦虑(n=13)、疼痛(n=9)、心理情绪反应和感知福祉(n=4)、压力(n=4)、癌症相关疲劳(n=3)、哭泣(n=2)。
临床怎么用
- 在医疗操作、术前麻醉诱导室和慢性病常规护理中,可考虑引入医院小丑以管理部分症状群。
- 医院小丑可能有助于改善住院儿童和青少年的心理福祉,相比仅接受标准护理。
局限性
- 多数随机对照试验存在一些担忧或高偏倚风险,非随机对照试验多为中等偏倚风险。
- 证据质量受限于纳入研究的偏倚风险,结论需谨慎解读。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate evidence from randomised controlled trials and non-randomised controlled trials on the effectiveness of hospital clowns for a range of symptom clusters in children and adolescents admitted to hospital with acute and chronic conditions. DESIGN: Systematic review of randomised and non-randomised controlled trials. DATA SOURCES: Medline, ISI of Knowledge, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, Science Direct, Scopus, American Psychological Association PsycINFO, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, and Latin American and Caribbean Health Sciences Literature. STUDY SELECTION: Randomised and non-randomised controlled trials were peer reviewed using the following eligibility criteria: children and adolescents who were admitted to hospital for acute conditions or chronic disorders, studies comparing use of hospital clowns with standard care, and studies evaluating the effect of hospital clowns on symptom management of inpatient children and adolescents as a primary outcome. DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Two investigators independently screened studies, extracted data, and appraised the risk of bias. Methodological appraisal was assessed by two investigators independently using the Jadad scale, the revised Cochrane risk-of-bias tool for randomised controlled trials (RoB 2), and the risk of bias in non-randomised studies (ROBINS-I) tool for non-randomised controlled trials. RESULTS: 24 studies (n=1612) met the inclusion criteria for data extraction and analysis. Most studies were randomised controlled trials (n=13). Anxiety was the most frequently analysed symptom (n=13), followed by pain (n=9), psychological and emotional responses and perceived wellbeing (n=4), stress (n=4), cancer related fatigue (n=3), and crying (n=2). Five studies used biomarkers, mainly cortisol, to assess stress or fatigue outcome following hospital clowns. Most of the randomised controlled trials (n=11; 85%) were rated as showing some concerns, and two trials were rated with a high risk of bias. Most non-randomised controlled trials (n=6; 55%) were rated with a moderate risk of bias according to ROBINS-I tool. Studies showed that children and adolescents who were in the presence of hospital clowns, either with or without a parent present, reported significantly less anxiety during a range of medical procedures, as well as improved psychological adjustment (P<0.05). Three studies that evaluated chronic conditions showed favourable results for the intervention of hospital clowns with significant reduction in stress, fatigue, pain, and distress (P<0.05). CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that the presence of hospital clowns during medical procedures, induction of anaesthesia in the preoperative room, and as part of routine care for chronic conditions might be a beneficial strategy to manage some symptom clusters. Furthermore, hospital clowns might help improve psychological wellbeing in admitted children and adolescents with acute and chronic disorders, compared with those who received only standard care. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42018107099.
引用
- Lopes-Júnior LC, Bomfim E, Olson K, et al. Effectiveness of hospital clowns for symptom management in paediatrics: systematic review of randomised and non-randomised controlled trials. BMJ. 2020. PMID: 33328164. doi:10.1136/bmj.m4290
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。