未发现基于真实世界数据的非随机对照研究与随机对照试验之间存在无法解释的分歧
该系统评价纳入12项研究、比较15个疗效估计值,评估基于真实世界数据的非随机对照研究(NRCS-RWD)与随机对照试验(RCT)的一致性。仅2个存在实质差异,均归因于NRCS-RWD的偏倚风险。外部有效性威胁对分歧影响无或微弱。
要点
- 仅2/15个估计值存在实质差异,均与NRCS-RWD偏倚风险相关。
- 外部有效性威胁对疗效估计分歧的影响无或微弱。
核心结论
- 在部分临床问题中,设计良好的NRCS-RWD与RCT之间偏倚风险差异可忽略。
- 外部有效性威胁对疗效估计分歧的影响无或微弱。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索比较同一临床问题NRCS-RWD与RCT疗效估计值的研究。
- 纳入12项研究,比较15个疗效估计值。
- 计算多种meta流行病学指标评估一致性,并分析分歧的可能原因。
主要发现
- 预测与观察重叠分析显示分歧未超出随机预期。
- 仅2个估计值存在实质差异,均将NRCS-RWD的偏倚风险列为最可能原因。
临床怎么用
- 对特定临床问题,可审慎参考设计良好的NRCS-RWD证据。
- 需重点评估NRCS-RWD的偏倚风险,而非仅因非随机设计否定其价值。
局限性
- 仅纳入12项研究、15个疗效估计值,样本量有限。
- 存在多种潜在分歧原因,难以完全归因。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: We assessed disagreements between nonrandomized controlled studies based on real-world data (NRCS-RWDs) and randomized controlled trials (RCTs). STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We systematically searched for studies that compared treatment effect estimates from NRCS-RWDs and RCTs on the same clinical question. We assessed the potential difference between NRCS-RWDs and RCTs related to internal and external validity. We calculated various meta-epidemiological measures to assess agreement. In case of disagreements, we tried to identify the probable causes of disagreements. RESULTS: We included 12 studies comparing 15 treatment effect estimates of NRCS-RWDs and RCTs. There were many potential causes of disagreement. Ninety-five percent confidence intervals overlapped for 12 of 15 treatment effect estimates. Our analysis on predicted vs. observed overlap showed that there were no more disagreements than expected by chance. We observed only two substantial differences between the 15 treatment effect estimates. In both cases, we identified risk of bias in the NRCS-RWDs as the most probable cause of disagreement. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest that there are clinical questions where the difference in risk of bias between a well-conducted NRCS-RWD and an RCT is negligible. In our analysis, threats to external validity appeared to have no or only a weak impact on the disagreements of treatment effect estimates.
引用
- Mathes T, Rombey T, Kuss O, et al. No inexplicable disagreements between real-world data-based nonrandomized controlled studies and randomized controlled trials were found. J Clin Epidemiol. 2021. PMID: 33359322. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.12.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。