文献速递流行病学与生物统计基础与转化研究

个体患者数据荟萃分析中患者特异性治疗效果估计方法的比较

Comparing methods for estimating patient-specific treatment effects in individual patient data meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Stat Med · 2020-12-27

个体患者数据(IPD)荟萃分析可个体化治疗推荐,但治疗-协变量交互项的选择方法尚不明确。本研究通过模拟比较标准方法(纳入所有交互项)与六种替代方法(逐步回归及五种收缩方法),发现收缩方法在连续和二分类结局中均表现良好,多数场景下患者特异性治疗效应的均方误差低于标准方法和逐步回归。建议未来旨在利用多个效应修饰因子估计患者特异性治疗效应的IPD荟萃分析采用收缩方法,避免逐步回归。

要点

  • 收缩方法在连续和二分类结局中均表现良好,多数场景下均方误差更低。
  • 标准方法(纳入所有交互项)和逐步回归的均方误差高于收缩方法。
  • 建议未来IPD荟萃分析采用收缩方法估计患者特异性治疗效应,避免逐步回归。

核心结论

  • 收缩方法在估计患者特异性治疗效应时多数场景下均方误差低于标准方法和逐步回归。
  • 建议未来旨在利用多个效应修饰因子估计患者特异性治疗效应的IPD荟萃分析采用收缩方法,避免逐步回归。

研究设计与样本

  • 通过模拟研究比较标准IPD荟萃分析方法(无变量选择,纳入所有治疗-协变量交互项)与六种替代方法:逐步回归、LASSO、岭回归、自适应LASSO、贝叶斯LASSO和随机搜索变量选择。
  • 探索多种场景,涵盖连续和二分类结局,并在心脏病学和精神病学两个数据集上示例应用。

主要发现

  • 收缩方法在连续和二分类结局、多种设置下均表现良好。
  • 多数场景下,收缩方法给出患者特异性治疗效应的均方误差低于标准方法和逐步回归。

临床怎么用

  • 未来IPD荟萃分析若旨在利用多个效应修饰因子估计患者特异性治疗效应,应使用收缩方法。
  • 应避免使用逐步回归进行变量选择。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Meta-analysis of individual patient data (IPD) is increasingly used to synthesize data from multiple trials. IPD meta-analysis offers several advantages over meta-analyzing aggregate data, including the capacity to individualize treatment recommendations. Trials usually collect information on many patient characteristics. Some of these covariates may strongly interact with treatment (and thus be associated with treatment effect modification) while others may have little effect. It is currently unclear whether a systematic approach to the selection of treatment-covariate interactions in an IPD meta-analysis can lead to better estimates of patient-specific treatment effects. We aimed to answer this question by comparing in simulations the standard approach to IPD meta-analysis (no variable selection, all treatment-covariate interactions included in the model) with six alternative methods: stepwise regression, and five regression methods that perform shrinkage on treatment-covariate interactions, that is, least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO), ridge, adaptive LASSO, Bayesian LASSO, and stochastic search variable selection. Exploring a range of scenarios, we found that shrinkage methods performed well for both continuous and dichotomous outcomes, for a variety of settings. In most scenarios, these methods gave lower mean squared error of the patient-specific treatment effect as compared with the standard approach and stepwise regression. We illustrate the application of these methods in two datasets from cardiology and psychiatry. We recommend that future IPD meta-analysis that aim to estimate patient-specific treatment effects using multiple effect modifiers should use shrinkage methods, whereas stepwise regression should be avoided.

来源:Stat Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Seo M, White IR, Furukawa TA, et al. Comparing methods for estimating patient-specific treatment effects in individual patient data meta-analysis. Stat Med. 2020. PMID: 33368415. doi:10.1002/sim.8859

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。